0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Pay $600 bucks for a brass L1 or buy a GHQ pewter L1 and hire someone to assemble and paint it... hmm... wonder which one will actually be cheaper???While I hope that they garner enough orders that they will consider other steamers such as the K4 among others their choice for a first offering is rather curious. Just don't know...
That's an easy one. Unless the assembler is working for slave wages, the brass engine will be cheaper.Mikado + GHQ kit = about $250. Yes, you might find it for less, but if you want a nice, clean, new one, that's a reasonable guess.That leaves $450, optimistically allowing as much as possible ($699 for the brass). Let's assume you can hire a very skilledmodel maker who will do this for $20/hr. That's only 22.5 hrs, barely 1/2 of a work week.I don't know about you, but I sure can't build and paint that L1 kit in 2 or 3 days, so the brass would be cheaper.(Unless Jason builds the L1, in which case, he would build it, paint it, cast and unrelated engine and make 20 shells, plusknock out two other molds and put a new roof on his house )
I have to admit that when I got the GHQ L-1, it intimidated me so completely the box got shelved for like three years.Then the Max M article came out in the PRRTHS magazine, and that got me restarted. It was all about the instructions. That exercise changed how I do my own kits, again, its all about the instructions. I love the description of the L1 kit as a 'gateway drug' to steam kitbashing, wow, is that ever true. After I got that built, I really wasn't afraid to take on much of anything, and ended up scratchbuilding my 28-ton Shay, the 30-ton Climax, and Lima 2-6-0 #5.I'm an ATSF fan trapped in PRR country, but my logging railroad prototype connected with the PRR. So that was the rationalization for doing at least one PRR hog. I have to admit I'm torn here. I want to support anybody that still wants to do brass, but wow... I can't pull the trigger when the GHQ model looks better, and pulls better, than any other N steam locomotive I own. http://pennsyrr.com/index.php/modeling/175-ghq-l1s-conversion-kit
Do you want to try your hand at a ATSF Northern /GS4 conversion....I'll send you one?
Seriously? Will I have to go to confession after?
Ahhh, but with the Kato model one does not get the proper slide or linkage...