0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I've even considered earmarking one hopper as "last car" and weighting the crap out of it to keep the slack out
JMHO, if you want to reliably eliminate the slinky, the only way is to take the springs out of the equation.HTH,Ed
I'm gonna ask a bunch of stupid-a$$ questions and I apologize in advance. I've not really been following this thread in a large part because I've only recently dove head-first back into N scale (my Colorado midland uses mostly Z-scale couplers anyway).How well do these couplers work in T-TRAK situations?Here's the deal... I was running a coal drag on Saturday at the RPM and the slinky effect was worse than I ever recall. Even my wife was making comments about it. Boing, boing, boing... Now, because my hopper fleet is made up of Micro-Trains, Bowser, and Blueford, it represents a roughly 70/30 mix of truck-mount to body mount couplers.I don't relish a fleet-wide coupler replacement program. I think I'd rather use a staple-gun on my naughty bits. But something needs to be done before I run another hopper train. I've even considered earmarking one hopper as "last car" and weighting the crap out of it to keep the slack out (Bowser N5 cabooses have no real room for extra weight or that'd be preferred).So... How do these hold up on tight turns? Must they only be body-mounted? And are they universally compatible with MTL and Accumate couplers?
Micro Trains has included these springs in their coupler kits (they're slightly larger in diameter and not as tightly wound as "normal" coupler centering springs) specifically to help minimize or eliminate slinky, but, for some reason, it's not well known that's what they're for.
This is a canonical example of what in engineering circles would be referred to as a "kludge".At essence, these serve to mask the problem, not solve it; furthermore they introduce problems of their own, such as reduced effective engine power, increased tendency to stringline, or have compression derailments when pushing (esp thru tight curves or turnouts). It's pretty much equivalent to moving cars with the brakes applied.Ed
All this slinky talk has got me confused (I thought N-Possibles did away with the slink!).Please tell me all this slinky talk has absolutely nothing to do with N-Possibles (another extreme thread drift? )
Yes, sorry… I should’ve specified that I am referring to the MTL slinky. I have never tried N-possible and came here wondering if it was a solution. I think the biggest LIMFAC would be compatibility with other couplers during the transition.