0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
The CNR cars are American Osgood Bradleys painted in CN colours. They are very close, but not 100%. The main differences are the trucks and the EM air conditioning. The CN cars had ice.
Reading the order page linked from the press release, am I to understand I can only order the CN cars direct from Rapido in Canada? Will these not be available through US dealers?
https://www.rapidotrains.com/n-osgood-bradley-coaches-2nd/So... I've been waiting to see the official release information before saying anything. Now that it is out, here it goes. I am disappointed with this announcement. I have always been a fan of the work you guys do, equally on the manufacturing side as well as the preservation side, and have always been ready to pay more to support these efforts. This is especially true when not many other manufacturers are willing to go to the lengths you guys typically go to for the market north of the border. For years Rapido has been making all sorts of great looking models, with a focus on niche Canadian products we never imagined could be brought to market in N scale. You built your reputation on delivering highly detailed models that are usually light years ahead of most of the competition, but more importantly you have prided yourselves in spending thousands of hours climbing all over actual rolling stock, doing laser scans of equipment, and going to all sorts of extremes so that you could produce truly accurate Canadian models, rather than slap a Canadian paint scheme on a US model. To say that the difference between an OB car and a balloon top (any class of balloon top) is mainly trucks and air conditioning is a slap in the face, particularly because you constantly state that you pay so much attention to the smallest of details. Other than the roof line and car length, the CC&F cars are quite a bit different from the OB cars. The window placement on all balloon top classes is completely different and that is quite a prominent feature when looking at passenger cars, never mind all the undercar, and end of car detailing. When the OB cars first came out, I had asked some of the Rapido staff at a local train show if we might ever see proper balloon tops. The answer was that the market likely wasn't large enough, and Rapido wouldn't compromise their reputation by releasing an inaccurate CNR car. This was an answer I highly respected. What changed?I am sure you guys did your homework and know that they will likely sell, but at that price I think I will just keep 3D printing, building and detailing my own balloon top cars. This post is not meant to bash the quality of the Rapido OB car by any means. Quite the opposite, I already have a few gorgeous NH and B&M cars in my fleet. Nor is it meant to dissuade you guys from bringing detailed Canadian models to market. But as far as the CNR "CC&F Balloon Top" cars go, I am disappointed. Respectfully,Fredrick