0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
.................................So while I agree that the bias toward code 80 has nothing to do with the rail size per se, I can sympathize with some people getting that impression when they hear about Atlas code 55 "failing". The message they hear, albiet incorrectly, is "code 55 is unreliable", when in fact, the correct message is that Atlas code 55 is fragile It looks great and it performs well once it is tweaked, but it does have a higher failure rate than the code 80 stuff.And to the Atlas company reps who frequent these boards, I apologize in advance if this sounds like I'm bashing. But I have seen enough issues with the code 55 track that the only honest conclusion I can come to is that it fails more and has more functional problems than the code 80, and it has nothing to do with the size of the rail.
N-Trak has now allowed the use of some Code 55 products for mail line applications. This was previously a Code 80 application only. Are you saying that N-Trak has misjudged the current Code 55 products and should not allow them where track reliability is critical?
NTrak allows Peco code 55 (as Peteski has pointed out), not Atlas.But even if they did, my remarks are not a condemnation of NTrak's judgment. If they one day decide to allow Atlas c55, it will be up to the builders of the individual modules to show up at shows with modules that work. The builder of an NTrak code 55 module will have to do more work to make sure, for example, the turnout rails are in gauge, that rails haven't popped out, etc. But if they are willing to take on that responsibility in exchange for better looking track, why not let them?The track is more fragile, which means it will require better setup and more care. But it only becomes a problem if the stuff is failing catastrophically at a lot of shows.
But does not mechanical incompatibility have a relationship to reliability?
The biggest reliability difference is in the roadbed. Code 80 is stiff enough, vertically, to bridge low spots, and to avoid abrupt vertical curves.
In a word: no. They are independent concepts. "Incompatible" basically means, 'don't expect these to work together at all'. One cannot judge the reliability of a system from trying to run it with incompatible components, that would be a meaningless exercise.Ed
But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation. The two concepts are related. Mechanically compatible parts work, mechanically incompatible parts are difficult to impossible to use. Mechanical compatibility and mechanical incompatibility are opposite sides of the same coin.Marty YoungSan Diego, CA
But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation.