Author Topic: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels  (Read 17100 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

atsf3751

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 253
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +20
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #60 on: March 16, 2017, 06:41:12 PM »
0
But does not mechanical incompatibility have a relationship to reliability? You can't have one without the other. If my trains do not run reliably on code 55 then I go to code 80. My definition of reliable operation may not be the same as yours.

Marty Young
San Diego, CA
Marty Young
San Diego, CA

leedabsme74

  • Posts: 19
  • Respect: +1
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #61 on: March 16, 2017, 09:05:15 PM »
0
.................................

So while I agree that the bias toward code 80 has nothing to do with the rail size per se, I can sympathize with some people getting that impression when they hear about Atlas code 55 "failing".  The message they hear, albiet incorrectly, is "code 55 is unreliable", when in fact, the correct message is that Atlas code 55 is fragile      It looks great and it performs well once it is tweaked, but it does have a higher failure rate than the code 80 stuff.

And to the Atlas company reps who frequent these boards, I apologize in advance if this sounds like I'm bashing.  But I have seen enough issues with the code 55 track that the only honest conclusion I can come to is that it fails more and has more functional problems than the code 80, and it has nothing to do with the size of the rail.

N-Trak has now allowed the use of some Code 55 products for mail line applications.  This was previously a Code 80 application only.  Are you saying that N-Trak has misjudged the current Code 55 products and should not allow them where track reliability is critical?

peteski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 35434
  • Gender: Male
  • Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
  • Respect: +6696
    • Coming (not so) soon...
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #62 on: March 16, 2017, 09:19:11 PM »
0
N-Trak has now allowed the use of some Code 55 products for mail line applications.  This was previously a Code 80 application only.  Are you saying that N-Trak has misjudged the current Code 55 products and should not allow them where track reliability is critical?

I believe that it is Peco C55 track that is allowed on NTRAK modules. Due to its construction, that track is much more robust than any C80 track.   I would say that it is the most robust N scale track ever made.  It is also compatible with the older N scale models which have deep flanges, and is seems to be always in stock.  :)
. . . 42 . . .

mmagliaro

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 6505
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +2014
    • Maxcow Online
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #63 on: March 16, 2017, 09:53:07 PM »
0
NTrak allows Peco code 55 (as Peteski has pointed out), not Atlas.

But even if they did, my remarks are not a condemnation of NTrak's judgment.  If they one day decide to allow Atlas c55, it will be up to the builders of the individual modules to show up at shows with modules that work. 
The builder of an NTrak code 55 module will have to do more work to make sure, for example, the turnout rails are in gauge, that rails haven't popped out, etc.  But if they are willing to take on that responsibility in exchange for better looking track, why not let them?

The track is more fragile, which means it will require better setup and more care.  But it only becomes a problem if the stuff is failing catastrophically at a lot of shows.


atsf3751

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 253
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +20
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #64 on: March 16, 2017, 11:25:41 PM »
0
I remember one NTrak module that was laid with code 80 and had to be removed from the layout several years ago. He had ballasted it with fish tank gravel (not carefully either) and that caused a lot of problems for most everyone. There is more involved in reliable operation than just the size of the rail.

Marty Young
San Diego, CA
Marty Young
San Diego, CA

nkalanaga

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 10610
  • Respect: +1776
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #65 on: March 17, 2017, 01:09:25 AM »
0
The biggest reliability difference is in the roadbed.  Code 80 is stiff enough, vertically, to bridge low spots, and to avoid abrupt vertical curves.  Code 55 is more flexible, and will follow the roadbed more closely.  If the roadbed isn't smooth, the track won't be, and the trains will be more likely to derail.

Given a perfect roadbed, the rail height won't make a bit of difference, as long as the flanges clear the spikes.
N Kalanaga
Be well

robert3985

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 3600
  • Respect: +1999
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #66 on: March 17, 2017, 02:27:29 AM »
0
Code 80 track, both Peco and Atlas, were specifically designed to be set up on green shag carpet, and worked pretty good that way.

Kato Unitrack, on the other hand, was specifically designed to be set up on tatami mats, although purely coincidentally, it works pretty good on green shag carpet too.  :D

Just sayin' !!

Cheerio!
Bob Gilmore



leedabsme74

  • Posts: 19
  • Respect: +1
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #67 on: March 17, 2017, 12:42:06 PM »
0
NTrak allows Peco code 55 (as Peteski has pointed out), not Atlas.

But even if they did, my remarks are not a condemnation of NTrak's judgment.  If they one day decide to allow Atlas c55, it will be up to the builders of the individual modules to show up at shows with modules that work. 
The builder of an NTrak code 55 module will have to do more work to make sure, for example, the turnout rails are in gauge, that rails haven't popped out, etc.  But if they are willing to take on that responsibility in exchange for better looking track, why not let them?

The track is more fragile, which means it will require better setup and more care.  But it only becomes a problem if the stuff is failing catastrophically at a lot of shows.

Thanks for your reply.  I agree with some of your comments.

ednadolski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5099
  • Respect: +2120
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #68 on: March 17, 2017, 02:39:48 PM »
+1
But does not mechanical incompatibility have a relationship to reliability?

In a word: no.  They are independent concepts.   "Incompatible" basically means, 'don't expect these to work together at all'.   One cannot judge the reliability of a system from trying to run it with incompatible components, that would be a meaningless exercise.

Ed

ednadolski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5099
  • Respect: +2120
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #69 on: March 17, 2017, 02:46:08 PM »
0
The biggest reliability difference is in the roadbed.  Code 80 is stiff enough, vertically, to bridge low spots, and to avoid abrupt vertical curves.

Low spots and abrupt vertical curves mean that the roadbed design and/or installation are defective.  Better to fix those issues and not depend on the stiffness of the heavier rail to mask those problems.

Ed

atsf3751

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 253
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +20
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #70 on: March 17, 2017, 04:30:58 PM »
0
In a word: no.  They are independent concepts.   "Incompatible" basically means, 'don't expect these to work together at all'.   One cannot judge the reliability of a system from trying to run it with incompatible components, that would be a meaningless exercise.

Ed

But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation. The two concepts are related. Mechanically compatible parts work, mechanically incompatible parts are difficult to impossible to use. Mechanical compatibility and mechanical incompatibility are opposite sides of the same coin.

Marty Young
San Diego, CA
Marty Young
San Diego, CA

mmagliaro

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 6505
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +2014
    • Maxcow Online
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #71 on: March 17, 2017, 08:00:33 PM »
+1

"But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation.  The two concepts are related. Mechanically compatible parts work, mechanically incompatible parts are difficult to impossible to use. Mechanical compatibility and mechanical incompatibility are opposite sides of the same coin."

I disagree.  All you can say is that if the parts are not compatible, you shouldn't even try.  Compatibility isn't an attribute of reliability, it is a requirement for usage of the parts.  It's not true that mechanically compatible parts "work".  All you can say is that they "fit".  They could still work like dog doo.

Consider this:
Let's consider 4 different types of track, all of which are compatible with each other and with a certain type of wheelset.  Yet for whatever reason, one of them suffers breakage a lot more than the other 3.  Maybe it was cheaper materials or a weak drawbar attachment.  Whatever the reason.  It doesn't matter.  The point is, all 4 were compatible.  All 4 fit.  And that tells you absolutely nothing about whether they are reliable.





peteski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 35434
  • Gender: Male
  • Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
  • Respect: +6696
    • Coming (not so) soon...
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #72 on: March 17, 2017, 10:27:59 PM »
+3
But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation. The two concepts are related. Mechanically compatible parts work, mechanically incompatible parts are difficult to impossible to use. Mechanical compatibility and mechanical incompatibility are opposite sides of the same coin.

Marty Young
San Diego, CA

What are we arguing about?  Pizza-cutter wheels were designed to a different standard than Atlas C55 track, and are incompatible. Period.  Reliability doesn't even enter this equation. Period.  To me you are confusing compatibility and reliability. They are not connected (like Ed stated, they are different concepts).

To be honest, using the word "reliability" in reference to entire line of track seems silly.  Reliability to me should really be used do describe how reliable (failure-free) are devices which have moving parts.  Things like a car engine, or the entire car, a motor or gears in an N scale model, a computer disk drive or even electronic devices such as your phone or a DCC decoder.

A piece of track is static and there is nothing that can really fail in normal use. But we can talk about reliability when evaluating parts of trackage such as switch points. But to  generalize and just describe the entire line of C55 track as less reliable than C80 doesn't really make sense to me.
. . . 42 . . .

nkalanaga

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 10610
  • Respect: +1776
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #73 on: March 18, 2017, 01:07:48 AM »
0
Ed:  Exactly my point.  If the roadbed isn't good to start with, heavier rail will compensate for some of the defects, but it still won't be "right". 

Reliability vs Compatibility:  Narrow gauge trains are as reliable as standard gauge, but the two are not compatible.
N Kalanaga
Be well

ednadolski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5099
  • Respect: +2120
Re: Plastic vs Metal vs Wide vs Narrow N scale wheels
« Reply #74 on: March 18, 2017, 11:03:49 AM »
0
But you can also say that if the parts are mechanically compatible then you are one step closer to reliable operation.

I guess one could say that compatibility is a necessary requirement for reliability. If the parts are incompatible, they will not work together at all (unless perhaps by coincidence) therefore the reliability is zero.

Reliability is "keeps working correctly".  WRT track & wheels, your operation should be reliable as long as keep the track clean, wheels & track remain in correct gauge, joints stay aligned, turnouts are built & maintained to correct standards [1], etc.  This also presupposes that you've avoided the design & construction defects such as the too-sharp curves and uneven track.  None of those factors are dependent upon the rail size - you can get just as good reliability from codes 80, 55, 40, or whatever you choose.

Ed

[1] N.B. the 'built' part.  Commercial turnouts are not necessarily built to the NMRA standards, in order to accommodate certain models that are themselves not conformant (e.g., pizza-cutter flanges).   If you want reliable interoperation, you have to use components that conform to the appropriate standards.  (This is where notorious problems like flangeway drop start creeping in.)