0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Whenever the topic of the CRR project RR comes up I wonder how they would do it today with the concept of staging added to the mix.
Agreed, and I also wonder if they would have used such tight curve radii today.
There was a Pacific Northwest version recently as a project in the N Scale Railroading magazine called the Spokane International. It had a slightly similar track plan to the Clinchfield but a little wider curves and more operating potential.
Most of the tighter curves were hidden in tunnels on the Clinchfield layout, so that mitigated much of their visual effect.One of the videos on the new Canadian Canyons layout mentions 15" to 17" radius curves, as compared to the 12" minimum on the Clinchfield. No doubt there's still been a trade off made to keep the layout size in check for portability.
I don't know why I thought they had some 10" curves... It also matters what you're running. As long as you're not running 89' TOFCs and auto parts boxcars you're probably OK. That's the nice thing about a coal railroad. Hoppers aren't long. I'm struggling to remember, but I imagine they had 6-axle SD power on that layout that did just fine, right?I do really like that layout. I wore my Dad's copy of the book ragged even when neither of us were in N scale.
I don't know why I thought they had some 10" curves...
I'll have to dig up my NSR back issues and pay attention to that one.
with a link to MRR for a track plan