... But the majority of the freight stuff is the McGinnis boxcar...
Decorated N scale models produced that are exact replicas of New Haven prototypes:
Freight:Athearn, 50' Boxcar DSD: red-orange New Image (2).
Atlas, 1945 International Caboose (NE6): as-built (4); red-orange New Image (4);
black/white New Image (2); all-black New Image (2); red-orange Alpert (2).
Atlas, PS-1 Boxcar SD: Script (2).
Atlas, PS-2 Cement Hopper: Script as-built (2); Script Alpert (3).
ESM, 40' Quad Offset Hopper: freight car red Script Alpert (2).
ESM, PC&F 40' Boxcar (XIH): State of Maine Script (5); freight car red Alpert (4).
InterMountain, AAR 1937 Boxcar SD: Script (12); red-orange New Image (4); black New Image (8 );
freight car red Alpert (4).
InterMountain, AAR 53' Flat: black Dumaine (6).
InterMountain, AAR 53' Bulkhead Flat: black Dumaine (6).
Kadee/MTL, 33' Twin Ribbed Hopper: black Dumaine (6).
Kadee/MTL, 33' Twin Ribbed Panel Hopper: black Dumaine (1).
Kadee/MTL, 50' Fishbelly Flatcar: black Dumaine (3).
Kadee/MTL, Scale Test Car: black Dumaine (1).
Red Caboose, 40' Flatcar: black Dumaine (12).
Motive Power:Atlas, RS-1: green/orange Script (3); red-orange Alpert (2).
Atlas, RS-11 (w/RS-12 fuel tank): black/red-orange New Image (5).
Atlas, RS-3: green/orange Script (2); red-orange Alpert (2).
Atlas, GP-9: black/red-orange New Image (7).
Atlas, GP-38: CNDOT New Image (3).
Atlas, U25B: black/red-orange New Image (8 ).
Bachmann, 4-8-2: (2).
Bachmann, GE 44T: black/red-orange New Image (1).
Kato, RDC1-4: Script (4).
Walthers, 0-8-0: (2).
Walthers/Life-Like, FA-1/FB-1: green Script (4).
Walthers/Life-Like, PA-1: green Script (2), orange/green Script (2).
Walthers/Life-Like, RS-2: green/orange Script (4); black/red-orange New Image (2).
Passenger:ESM, 14-4 Sleeper: Script (4); New Image (4).
Buildings:Branchline: Caanan Union Station.
Branchline: Cannondale Station.
N Scale Architect: New Haven Tower.
Existing plastic that is 100% accurate but has yet to be released in New Haven schemes:InterMountain: AAR 40' "Pacemaker" Boxcar
MTL: Heavyweight 28-1 Parlor
MTL: Heavyweight 12-1 Sleeper
Announced plastic that is 100% accurate and due within the next 18 months:Rapido: Pullman-Bradley Light Weight intercity coach
Rapido: Pullman-Bradley Light Weight intercity coach w/smoking lounge
This list doesn't include another dozen or so models that are 90% accurate, nor does it include the dozen or so brass or undecorated kits that are railroad-specific.
New Haven is the best-represented of the smaller Class I roads in N, hands down, and also that's with it being a railroad that utilized a ton of esoteric equipment. If you can't find prototypical New Haven equipment in N scale, you're not looking very hard. And you're incorrect about most of the N scale freight equipment being decorated in the New Image scheme. It's not even close.
One pet peeve of mine — McGinnis was NH president for a mere 21 months. Although he initiated the image makeover, most of the rollout occurred after he was gone. The scheme was officially designated as "New Image" by the railroad, not "McGinnis". The austerity New Image scheme was implemented during the Alpert regime around 1960.