0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I can offer the following based on some limited experience. MR would be happy to discuss quality N scale articles with anyone. The "token" N scale comment is not really fair - the fact is they are always looking for good N scale material. There's more competition for N scale material than any other scale since there are four print magazines, and one online magazine, all competing for "N scale stuff." Frankly, a good N scale submission - with quality photos, and good modeling, has a better chance than an equivalent HO project of getting accepted. I suggest you pick up the phone and talk to them - 262-796-8776 - ask for Neil Besougoloff or David Popp. Both are really nice guys to talk with.
I think overall there are fewer top notch prototypical N scale layouts period the average modeler is satisfied with the really bad models and simple Kato unitrack with toy like looking scenery I find so much of this on youtube and when you search HO there are much more convincing layouts from an prototypical accuracy stand point. Which is frustrating because N can be just as good if not better than HO do to the ability to include more scale size scenes. The work on this forum is top notch but unfortunately scarce elsewhere I think due to the fact it is harder for most to work in great detail and scale fidelty in a smaller scale and also because it is just in the last few years we have been getting models we don't have to lower and all that. A lot of the older rolling stock kills the appearance of an otherwise awesome video shot or photo. We also recently in N have finally got more accurate structures and signals ect that rival any HO model thanks to people like DKS and Traincat but few of the videos I see use these awesome models they usually use older model power, con cor, bachmann ect ect signals and rolling stock Youtube is a good indicator of whats out there in my opinion and the great layouts in N are few and far in between.
Phil,I never said I was a typist.Bill
Plus we be postin' from phones & stuff.
Assuming I'm reading this correctly, you posit that N scale has a disproportionately larger number of poorly executed layouts than do the other scales (or at least HO). I'm not sure I agree.
I still think there's a lingering mentality hobby-wide that N scale is more of a novelty, belonging in a coffee table or a suitcase. Tony Koester has all but decreed that when one ages, one must upsize in scale because of failing eyes. This in spite of the fact that most people downsize their home at that time, and N scale is much better suited for a condo or smaller home.
I guess you could say model railroading media has gentrified
Not to be condescending, I was just relating informal conversations with MR staffers. About the level of writing we put into our posts, I am told that is what they often get in submissions.
If that's all the attention you put in a photo, what corners do you cut in your modeling?
Dave,Not to be condescending, I was just relating informal conversations with MR staffers. About the level of writing we put into our posts, I am told that is what they often get in submissions. And the most common complaint, photos! About this I can't help but be harsh: most photos here display a lack of skill or a high level of no attention to detail, and I think that photos here should display all the attention to detail put in a photo for a magazine. Oh sure, you're just putting in a little something for us to get the idea, but if it isn't all in focus, either get it so or crop out that that doesn't matter. If that's all the attention you put in a photo, what corners do you cut in your modeling?Bill