Author Topic: How easy is it to get an N scale article published in (HO) Model Railroader Mag?  (Read 7031 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Dave V

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 12424
  • Gender: Male
  • Foothills Farm Studios -- Dave's Model Railroading
  • Respect: +12072
I can offer the following based on some limited experience.  :? MR would be happy to discuss quality N scale articles with anyone. The "token" N scale comment is not really fair - the fact is they are always looking for good N scale material. There's more competition for N scale material than any other scale since there are four print magazines, and one online magazine, all competing for "N scale stuff."
Frankly, a good N scale submission - with quality photos, and good modeling, has a better chance than an equivalent HO project of getting accepted.
I suggest you pick up the phone and talk to them - 262-796-8776 - ask for Neil Besougoloff or David Popp. Both are really nice guys to talk with.

Don't get me wrong, I'm incredibly humbled to be featured in GMR...  This is certainly the highlight of my 30 years in the hobby!  The big leagues!  However, I still feel that N scale is underrepresented in GMR.  I know I don't have the stats to back that up, but it's just the impression I get, fair or not.

I can't speak to the monthly MR.  Before I got a decent DSLR I used to be scared off by the photography standards.  But now what drives me away is the fact that so many bylines are about "the late so-and-so" who died 2 years before the article made print.  Fortunately, GMR is an annual so that's not an issue.

I think overall there are fewer top notch prototypical N scale layouts period the average modeler is satisfied with the really bad models and simple Kato unitrack with toy like looking scenery I find so much of this on youtube and when you search HO there are much more convincing layouts from an prototypical accuracy stand point. Which is frustrating because N can be just as good if not better than HO do to the ability to include more scale size scenes. The work on this forum is top notch but unfortunately scarce elsewhere I think due to the fact it is harder for most to work in great detail and scale fidelty in a smaller scale and also because it is just in the last few years we have been getting models we don't have to lower and all that. A lot of the older rolling stock kills the appearance of an otherwise awesome video shot or photo. We also recently in N have finally got more accurate structures and signals ect that rival any HO model thanks to people like DKS and Traincat but few of the videos I see use these awesome models they usually use older model power, con cor, bachmann ect ect signals and rolling stock :facepalm: Youtube is a good indicator of whats out there in my opinion and the great layouts in N are few and far in between.

Assuming I'm reading this correctly, you posit that N scale has a disproportionately larger number of poorly executed layouts than do the other scales (or at least HO).  I'm not sure I agree.  I don't usually like to condescend about others' modeling but I've seen some highly mediocre modeling in HO too, and in numbers per capita on par with what I've seen in N.  Indeed, there is a lot of banality to be found in N (perhaps made more visible through N Trak), but I'm just not buying that it represents a higher fraction of the scale than it does in HO.

I still think there's a lingering mentality hobby-wide that N scale is more of a novelty, belonging in a coffee table or a suitcase.  Tony Koester has all but decreed that when one ages, one must upsize in scale because of failing eyes.  This in spite of the fact that most people downsize their home at that time, and N scale is much better suited for a condo or smaller home.
« Last Edit: August 24, 2013, 12:05:44 AM by Dave Vollmer »

SkipGear

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 2431
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +647
I have a friend that is trying to tip the ballance in MR. He has a scheduled photo shoot with Lou Sassi coming up. I believe Lou was in town a couple years back and someone told him that he needed to stop by and see the layout (which was only partialy finished at the time). He said, "Call me when you are closer, this should definitely be in the magazine." That time is coming and he is rushing to finish up details on the layout for the shoot.

The layout standards are pretty high, the majority of structures on the layout are completely scratch built along with the various bridges on the loop. It is most certainly not a cookie cutter, purchase and place layout.

We are hoping the FVM GP60M's arrive before the photo shoot to help set the era of the layout.
Tony Hines

bill pearce

  • Guest
Phil,

I never said I was a typist.

Bill

Dave V

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 12424
  • Gender: Male
  • Foothills Farm Studios -- Dave's Model Railroading
  • Respect: +12072
Phil,

I never said I was a typist.

Bill

I have to back up my man Phil...  If we can't judge your writing by the quality of your posts, then I don't think you can judge our writing by our posts.  Although I try generally to write everything with the same degree of diligence, I find it highly, highly unlikely that your average Railwire member puts the same degree of polish on a post that he might on a manuscript.  I found your post condescending and frankly unfounded considering just how many people on this forum have published in the model railroad press, including Kalmbach.

GaryHinshaw

  • Global Moderator
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 6800
  • Respect: +2669
Bill, when I first read your post, I thought the inference that "only one or two members here could meet their writing standards" was so absurd that it was merely rhetorical.  But now I wonder if you really believe that.  Comparing forum contributions to magazine contributions is like comparing having beers with your buddies to attending a state dinner (of course I exaggerate).  The purpose and formality of the two are completely different.  We're here to exchange ideas, show off our work now and then, and banter with friends, not to insult them.

-Gary

Chris333

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 19707
  • Respect: +6987
Plus we be postin' from phones & stuff.

tom mann

  • Administrator
  • Crew
  • *****
  • Posts: 10921
  • Representing The Railwire on The Railwire
  • Respect: +1017
    • http://www.chicagoswitching.com
Plus we be postin' from phones & stuff.

I'm posting this from a super computer with an extra large keyboard positioned in the middle of my MR-featured layout. :trollface:

John

  • Administrator
  • Crew
  • *****
  • Posts: 14023
  • Respect: +4193
Assuming I'm reading this correctly, you posit that N scale has a disproportionately larger number of poorly executed layouts than do the other scales (or at least HO).  I'm not sure I agree.

 I think your statement is fairly true -- but since none of us have any statistics other than our own empirical biases, everything we post in this thread is based on our own perceptions.

I've seen some really nice N layouts featured on the forums, both here and others, and believe we have a good group of talented modelers.  Just to be clear,  I don't consider my work to be among that group. (and not looking for rebuttal on that point).

Each of us has a threshold for what we think is good.   At the risk of alienating anyone - It's hard to make N Scale models look realistic .. we just don't have the detail parts that scale down to fine windows, doors, etc .. for the most part, our structures look sort of clunky when compared to HO or S or O ..  some folks here   -- I won't mention any names to not risk leaving anyone out --- have the touch to reach the levels of realism that will make you wonder --- is it HO or N .. but by and large, most of us haven't gotten there . .myself included .. it's just a fact of life .. N and Z are hard to work in .. at least at the super detail level you can get in HO ..


Quote
I still think there's a lingering mentality hobby-wide that N scale is more of a novelty, belonging in a coffee table or a suitcase.  Tony Koester has all but decreed that when one ages, one must upsize in scale because of failing eyes.  This in spite of the fact that most people downsize their home at that time, and N scale is much better suited for a condo or smaller home.

Yea .. that's unfortunate .. but one thing I've often wondered is if I had scaled my plans down to an HCD or maybe a layout the size of the Lee's former footprint that I could have accomplished more more greatness and less mediocrity camouflaged by sheer volume ..    especially since I tend to be a lone wolf modeler.

The comments so far have been pretty informative .. the tips provided by the published authors are informative .. We shouldn't take them as an indictment of our own abilities .. but as points of reference based on their perspective of having submitted material to MR that's been accepted ..

So, I hope I haven't offended anyone ..   hows my writing style :)


« Last Edit: August 24, 2013, 08:30:32 AM by John »

Rossford Yard

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 1202
  • Respect: +165
Never had anything published, but when I sent my subscription into NSR, I sent a few layout photos, and they displayed interest and gave some helpful hints as to how to get an article in, which might apply to MR>

Basically they suggest starting with not waiting until the layout is complete.  Finish a scene and get that in whatever the magazines equivalent to MR's Trackside Scenes is.  Sort of like the first piece of candy being free....

As to writing, I actually do write for one magazine and one website.  Overall, the writing here doesn't seem bad at all!  That said, the typical writing for publication means writing whatever you want to write, and then editing it by half, then about half again to meet your word limit.  After all, magazines these days are all about what one editor calls "toilet reads."

OldEastRR

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 3803
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +518
Thinking what you see in the model RR mags is what most model railroads are is like expecting that most people live in the houses you see in Architectural Digest and Homes Beautiful -- every layout in the mags exquisite, superdetailed, craftsman-level museum quality types. Figure that unless your layout looks like George Sellios's, don't expect to get into a mag.
Wasn't always this way. Experimental versions, re-used material car builds, Rube-Goldberg-like do-thingies for achieving this or that special effect ... those used to be standard fare for the model mags in the 40s and 50, and even into the 70's. Pics of a layout on a plywood shelf with 2x4's for supports, or one of bare track and cardboard cut-out structures along the backdrop? Yep, all that was there. One article was how a guy made a large-scale train set with home=made equipment that rolled on empty canned milk cans! To me, it seemed like the mags of old were much like these forums today, a bunch of guys fooling around and seeing what they can come up with that hasn't been done before.
The last vestiges of the "hey this is my idea of model RRing" left when MR dropped the Student Fare section. Now overwhelmingly you see either super-high ability work like fantastic layouts and intensive loco-modification/extreme detailing articles, or simple ones like how to ballast track, make trees, and weather stuff. I guess you could say model railroading media has gentrified, and poor dumb slobs aren't quite good enough to be in them

bill pearce

  • Guest
Dave,

Not to be condescending, I was just relating informal conversations with MR staffers. About the level of writing we put into our posts, I am told that is what they often get in submissions. And the most common complaint, photos! About this I can't help but be harsh: most photos here display a lack of skill or a high level of no attention to detail, and I think that photos here should display all the attention to detail put in a photo for a magazine. Oh sure, you're just putting in a little something for us to get the idea, but if it isn't all in focus, either get it so or crop out that that doesn't matter. If that's all the attention you put in a photo, what corners do you cut in your modeling?

Bill

Scottl

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5307
  • Respect: +2619
Quote
I guess you could say model railroading media has gentrified

That is a good way of putting it in the case of MR. 

Scottl

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5307
  • Respect: +2619
Quote
Not to be condescending, I was just relating informal conversations with MR staffers. About the level of writing we put into our posts, I am told that is what they often get in submissions.

I can't argue with photographs, but editors should expect to do their job:  editing.  Most articles are a few hundred words and would require an hour of editing by a professional.  Good grief.

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
If that's all the attention you put in a photo, what corners do you cut in your modeling?

Speaking strictly for myself, the vast majority of images I post here are for instructional purposes rather than to showcase magazine-ready scenes. There's a point of diminishing returns when taking online photos. And I post quite a few of them. If I were to take that time and invest it in each and every photo I post, I would have almost no time left for modeling. That said, I don't cut corners in my modeling in proportion to what may be perceived as flaws in my images. On those occasions when I'm ready to do a mag-quality set shot, I will take the time and work to get it right. But those occasions are few and far between.

As for Model Railroader, I personally think it's reached the point where it sells itself based almost entirely on high-gloss eye candy ("gentrified" is a perfect way of putting it). Their lofty submission expectations are designed to satisfy a publishing style that I do not find particularly instructive or inherently valuable, because beneath that veneer of über-quality imagery is an increasing lack of good solid useful content.

The Railwire is not MR Online, and I think it's a huge mistake to regard it as such or expect to see wall-to-wall publishing-grade quality images--or writing, for that matter.
« Last Edit: August 24, 2013, 01:32:54 PM by David K. Smith »

Dave V

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 12424
  • Gender: Male
  • Foothills Farm Studios -- Dave's Model Railroading
  • Respect: +12072
Dave,

Not to be condescending, I was just relating informal conversations with MR staffers. About the level of writing we put into our posts, I am told that is what they often get in submissions. And the most common complaint, photos! About this I can't help but be harsh: most photos here display a lack of skill or a high level of no attention to detail, and I think that photos here should display all the attention to detail put in a photo for a magazine. Oh sure, you're just putting in a little something for us to get the idea, but if it isn't all in focus, either get it so or crop out that that doesn't matter. If that's all the attention you put in a photo, what corners do you cut in your modeling?

Bill

I disagree with this even more.

Sometimes in a rush to share my work in progress here I use iPhone grabs and post them online.  I would never do that for a magazine.

And relating photographic diligence to modeling skill is even more condescending.