Author Topic: How easy is it to get an N scale article published in (HO) Model Railroader Mag?  (Read 7032 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

spookshow

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 2184
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +2471
    • Model Railroading Projects & Resources

I think this is pretty accurate ...

Assuming we're only talking about layout articles.

-Mark

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
Youtube is a good indicator of whats out there in my opinion and the great layouts in N are few and far in between.

I'd have to disagree. Usually social media tends to attract people of like mind, so it may be that the N scale RTR crowd is dominant there, which doesn't mean there aren't any good N scale layouts. I don't think it's possible to point to any single venue as an indicator of the state of the hobby or a segment thereof. I suspect there are many more good N scale modelers out there than we'll know, except perhaps by an absurdly lengthy door-to-door census.
« Last Edit: August 23, 2013, 04:17:04 PM by David K. Smith »

peteski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 35436
  • Gender: Male
  • Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
  • Respect: +6696
    • Coming (not so) soon...
My only publishing experience was a 2-part, 20-page total, article in N-Scale Mag. I first contacted the editor with the idea and a basic outline of the article.  The editor was interested.

I then composed the article exactly how I would like it to appear in the magazine.  I looked at couple of issues of N-Scale and based my article layout and style on how the published articles appeared in the magazine.

I then sent my article in (on a CD). Besides the standard format requested by the editor, I also included a PDF file presenting my article just as if it was shown on the pages of the magazine.  The article was published just couple months later. To me it seemed very quick. It was also published with almost no edits done, both to the text and to the photos.  My PDF version and the actual article in the magazine were virtually identical. I was very pleasantly surprised.   The payment I received was also pleasantly surprising.

Overall, it was a good experience. I have few more N-scale specific articles planned and I will either try to get them published in the N Scale Mag or in NSR.  I am also planning on writing an article on scratchbuilding modern streetlights.  While it is for N scale, it can easily be adapted to any scale. I'll try to get this one published in the Model Railroader.

The closest I came to an article being published in the Model Railroader Magazine is when I was assisting my friend in his article.  The photos were shot by Lou Sassi, and the rest was done by my friend.  It took over a year for that article to show up in print.

On a semi-related note, one thing that really bugs me about Model Railroader is that they publish articles about electronic circuits, without having the circuit reviewed by someone who understands electronic design.  There were several articles where the author, with a hobbyist's level of electronics, created a circuit which does work, but it is not designed well.  The same circuit could have been easily redesigned by someone really familiar with electronic design, resulting in the same functionality but with either less complicated circuit, or one which doesn't waste lots of power (as heat). To me this kind of "electronics" is detrimental to the hobby.
« Last Edit: August 23, 2013, 04:32:52 PM by peteski »
. . . 42 . . .

rickb773

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 603
  • Gender: Male
  • Rickb773
  • Respect: +1071
    • Pennsylvania-Reading Seashore Lines
I have to agree with Peteski. I have had 2 (layout) articles published in N Scale Magazine and Pam was a joy to work with. They did somewhat butcher the first article since I just sent them a bunch of photos  with the article and their choice and layout left something to be desired. For my second  article I basically laid out for them my suggestions and they seem to follow them closely. Both were published within a few months of submission.

bill pearce

  • Guest
I have been published in MR a couple of dozen times, and in N-Scale, NSR and RMJ. I have had experience over some time, and am anticipating contributing more as time allows. In the case of MR, it is true that most staffers are HO modelers, and they depend on over-the-transom submissions for N. The big problem for most is their standards. They expect you modeling to be first rate, your photos exceptional and your writing skills professional. I expect that many of the heavy handed editing complaints are the results of poor English composition skills. Very very few of the photos I see on this very forum would be accepted by MR. As some one that has made a living at professional writing and photography for around 40 years, let me tell you that they expect only the best. To open the wound further, there are only one or two of you posting on this forum that meet their writing standards. On balance they pay the best and unlike most others, up front.

Of what's left, the only other mag I would submit to is NSR. Kirk is a great guy.

Oh how I miss RMJ.

Bill Pearce

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
I have to agree with Peteski. I have had 2 (layout) articles published in N Scale Magazine and Pam was a joy to work with. They did somewhat butcher the first article since I just sent them a bunch of photos  with the article and their choice and layout left something to be desired. For my second  article I basically laid out for them my suggestions and they seem to follow them closely. Both were published within a few months of submission.

This is not a surprise. Smaller magazines will naturally have a smaller staff, and their artist(s) may not be particularly strong. On the flipside, they also won't have very stringent design rules, if any, so if an author submits a page layout, that's less work for them. Contrast this with, say, Model Railroader, where they have carved-in-stone layout guidelines, as well as a staff of seasoned designers at their disposal. Any page designs submitted to them will almost certainly be ignored.

Very very few of the photos I see on this very forum would be accepted by MR.

When one is shooting for a forum post, one likely isn't going for five-star publishing quality every time. :trollface: I think a number of us here could muster the extra energy required to generate MR-acceptable images.
« Last Edit: August 23, 2013, 06:49:15 PM by David K. Smith »

Scottl

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5307
  • Respect: +2619
Quote
To open the wound further, there are only one or two of you posting on this forum that meet their writing standards.

You do not want some of us writing on here as we do in our day jobs!

Having read the best writing of literally hundreds of young adults and colleagues with decades of writing experience, I suspect you are quite correct.  Most people cannot write to magazine standards.  Good editors are worth their weight in gold.

Coxy

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 180
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +7
    • Coxy's N Scale and Railroading Blog
Interesting that writing quality is coming up as a potential stumbling block.

My co-author for the track planning article is a journalist and I have done a lot of writing and editing in my professional career. We probably went through about 10 - 12 drafts of our article before submission.

I should also note, MR was very good to deal with and paid up front for 6 full pages but published 4 in the end which was fine by us. They handled all editorial work post submission.

jereising

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 750
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +610
    • The Oakville Sub
I submitted two articles maybe a year and a half apart.

They accepted and immediately paid for the two articles.

It took over a year in each case from acceptance to publication.

The editor assigned to me worked with me on the first article.  I was reasonably happy with the results.

The second article had no communication, they simply published, cutting out the beginning and ending that to me made the difference between an article and a good read.  I'm still reasonable happy with the results.

And I think there are more good writers on this forum than you may think...

Jim Reising
Visit The Oakville Sub - A Different Tehachapi - at:
http://theoakvillesub.itgo.com/
And on Trainboard:
http://www.trainboard.com/grapevine/showthread.php?t=99466

Loren Perry

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 289
  • Respect: +116
My views are heavily influenced by the fact that I was a hobby magazine editor for a number of years in the 1980's (Scale Ship Modeler from Challenge Publications) so I'm aware of both sides of the coin here. This said, I've been fortunate to have had some N-scale articles published by N Scale magazine and I agree with those here who say editor/publisher Pam (and now editor Walt Huston) are fine people to work with. My articles are submitted with my clear permission to edit as they see fit. In almost ever case, they use my copy verbatim as well as most, if not all the photos I send in, although I do include a number of alternate photos for them to select from.

Their next issue (Nov/Dec 2013) will feature another of my submissions and I'm looking forward to seeing how Walt handles it. Up until now, I've always worked with Pam, but I'm not expecting any major changes.

I don't know if I'm unique in this respect, but Pam and her crew have always e-mailed me a rough copy of each article's layout for my approval or for corrections. After a quick but thorough review, I'll send them my input and they'll finalize it for print. The end result has always been exactly how they told me it would appear.

Once in a while, they'll ask for a special photo for the cover shot.  I always send them several images of the same subject taken from different angles and with different lighting and I make it a point to "take direction" from them cheerfully when it's needed.

Because I've sent them quite a few articles over the years (some yet to be published), I understand when they delay them now and then to give other writers a chance so it's no problem for me.  I typically receive a payment check just prior to the magazine hitting the newsstand. FWIW, I have told them repeatedly that I don't require or expect payment at all. I do this just for fun. This is the one and only area where they ignore my wishes.

I've never approached Model Railroader or any other magazine to date. MR's style of editing strikes me as "plain vanilla", or a one-size-fits-all type of rewriting where the end result is every article seems to be written by the same person. N Scale Railroading is a lot looser and the personality of the writer is more evident. I never wrote for Rail Model Journal when it was around but the editor/publisher requested a photo of an N-scale Southern Pacific GP-9 I had just built with Gold Medal Models parts on it. The photo was intended for use in their New Products section but they ended up putting it on the cover in one of their mid-1990's issues. When I first saw that issue, I didn't even recognize my own model - I thought it was someone else's HO or O-scale model due to the excellent quality of their photo reproduction. It wasn't until I read the cover credit on the inside that I realized it was mine.

I've very comfortable with N-Scale magazine and their pleasant ways of working with me.
« Last Edit: August 23, 2013, 08:27:57 PM by Loren Perry »

randgust

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 3289
  • Respect: +3010
    • Randgust N Scale Kits
I've done both MR and RMC articles.   I got pretty frustrated with MR during the Kelly years, had a devil of a time with meeting their high photography standards and then I waited over a year for it to appear.   So I got to do it, crossed off my bucket list of 'lifes list of things I want to do', but it's a lot of work.     

RMC was sure a lot easier to work with for a feature article, but for whatever reason, it took FOREVER to get paid.  Seriously.   So I also marked that off my bucket list.   Equally frustrating for different reasons.

Just got an article accepted by TRAINS, we'll see how many years it takes to actually appear.    I've had Kalmbach pay me for three TRAINS articles that never saw print.

I just find it much easier to make and sell kits to make some extra $$$ instead of writing and waiting...waiting..waiting....

Philip H

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9030
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +1797
    • Layout Progress Blog
Hey Bill, I can appreciate what you say, but it would be a tad more impactful if it didn't have a rather glaring typo in the middle.

As to the rest, I respectfully submit that if our writing skills as displayed here don't meet MR standards then this isn't the place to look for that sort of writing. Granted, I don't have as many by-lines as others here, but when I see generalized indictments of writing skill or composition, I tend to dismiss them.  I find such criticism to be useless, because it offers no way to assess my own work against the supposed standard. In addition a lot of what I write here (like this post) is on a less then full sized cell phone virtual keyboard. I don't like to use that forever.
Philip H.
Chief Everything Officer
Baton Rouge Southern RR - Mount Rainier Division.


spookshow

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 2184
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +2471
    • Model Railroading Projects & Resources
Wow, we can't write and we have crappy layouts to boot? No wonder we're not in MR!

Cheers (I guess),
-Mark  :P

peteski

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 35436
  • Gender: Male
  • Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
  • Respect: +6696
    • Coming (not so) soon...
Their next issue (Nov/Dec 2013) will feature another of my submissions and I'm looking forward to seeing how Walt handles it. Up until now, I've always worked with Pam, but I'm not expecting any major changes.

I don't know if I'm unique in this respect, but Pam and her crew have always e-mailed me a rough copy of each article's layout for my approval or for corrections. After a quick but thorough review, I'll send them my input and they'll finalize it for print. The end result has always been exactly how they told me it would appear.

I agree that seeing the rough copy of the editor's version of my article, before it being published, was very valuable.  Each time, I discovered either an editing mistake on their part, or something I missed in the text (even though I proof-read, and modified, my article about 15 times before sending it in). IMO, it is an excellent idea to have the author give the final seal of approval. After all it is the author, not the editor, who truly understands what their article is supposed to convey. I don't think that MR does that, as they often publish corrections in the subsequent issues.

I didn't work with Pam, but with Andy Schlotfeldt. This might been during the transition between Pam and Walt. Andy was also super-easy to deal with.

As for Bill Pearce's comment, honest or not, I don't think he is making any friends in this thread. But then again, I can relate to that - kind of reminds me of the times I stuck a foot in my mouth on my keyboard.  :facepalm:
« Last Edit: August 23, 2013, 11:18:43 PM by peteski »
. . . 42 . . .

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
Hey Bill, I can appreciate what you say, but it would be a tad more impactful if it didn't have a rather glaring typo in the middle.

Happens even to the best of the best... :trollface:

Further to the point on writing, it's a bit tricky making that sort of judgment by virtue of what one sees on a forum. It's not as if we're working toward a Pulitzer with each post; this is by nature an informal venue, and writing will naturally be significantly looser. But I'm probably being Captain Obvious with that observation.