0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I feel a strange need to buy a comet car....
The SP car appears to be reasonably accurate. It represents a very small class of just two cars. Later conversions eliminated the doors. Time frame is accurate however these and the later conversions were dedicated to bulk sugar service.
So that we don't get into another "icebreaker" errr...."conversation", can anyone supply info on the Southern and SP "boxcar/hopper" cars? The description supplied by MT begins "In the early twentieth century there was an increasing need to transport dry goods in bulk by rail." But these are clearly 1950s or later. In fact, shop dates on the SP car are 1953 and on the Southern car 1968. I am aware of "drop bottom" boxcars and stockcars going back to the late 19th or early 20th century, but these are clearly not those. Appear to be a MTL "standard" PS-1 boxcar modified with hopper bays and hatches. For my own modeling purposes, I could use the SP car if the 1953 date is accurate. The 1942 build date on the car would indicate that the PS-1 is "standing in" for a 1937 or 1937 modified boxcar. But I might let that slide just to have the conversation piece sitting on a siding near a grain elevator among a bunch of boxcars and a couple covered hoppers (my planned layout is 1956 when most grain was still moving in boxcars).
28000 series as D&H cement car would be another option, but it would need different hatches and outlets:I can't find an online picture of the prototype, Tichy Train Group HO model is the closest thing I could find:https://www.tichytraingroup.com/Shop/tabid/91/p/4030-usra-cement-car/Default.aspx