I received my craftsman quality built-up Woodbury Station from Right on Track Models and was amazed at the workmanship. It will now become the centerpiece of my PRSL layout.
It did, however have several issues which did not show up on any of the other kits delivered in the larger scales. These issues have been forwarded to the manufacturer for possible corrections in the future but many are characteristics that are difficult to control in N scale.
Color SelectionAlthough I model Woodbury and Westville around 1950, instead of traditional PRR Station colors (which visitors to my layout may not notice), I wanted a cream to match the current station/restaurant color. I was presented with a selection palette that did not include anything close so I asked for antique white. Instead, I got a brown which neither highlighted the beautiful craftmanship done by Right on Track Models nor created the ability to recognize that the station was a special representation of the one currently in Woodbury.
I am basically color blind so leaning on the eyes of the AAA Hobbies worker to match a photo, we chose Model Color’s Pale Sand. I basically dry brush painted the base model and weathered it. (Since I was over painting a brown model, I probably should have gone with the “Iced Yellow”.
Platform Roof IssuesI initially thought the base was warped into a mild U shape but the station platform roofs were so warped that they pulled up the station platform ends also pulling the center of the base away from the structure allowing light to show throw the center bottom. I separated the model from the base and attempted to fix the roof center support structure to straighten the roof which was pulling away from its supports. All platform roofs were warping and needed to be AC’d in multiple places along to the center roof structure.
I assume these problems were due to the thin wood materials being painted on only one side,
BaseThe “concrete” base was made out of thin wood and warped (probably from the warped platform roofs or painting one side only). I replaced it with an Evergreen styrene plastic sheet for stability.
Unpainted corner trim
Several station corners were installed unpainted so I needed to paint them in Hunter Green.
Missing end inserts to secondary passenger shelter.Right on Track Models supplied some spare pieces which I painted and installed (a real nightmare). (See next photo)
Woodbury Station SignsInconsistent sign trim stood out like a sore thumb. Right on Track Models graciously provided a sheet of consistently printed replacement signs
Corner side separation.Did not attempt to correct. (See the Unpainted Corner Trim photo)
Uneven side platform roofI was going to trim the connecting roof but thought it was the other side and had already glued the offending side in place so there it stays. (See the Unpainted Corner Trim photo)
Misplaced station support post holes on rear.When I replaced the base, I predrilled the holes from the existing floor. I later noticed that the initial positions had caused the support posts to significantly bow inward so I had to redrill a second set of holes further from the station to allow the posts to be straight.
Secondary Passenger ShelterThis should have been twice as long as the one produced but does include the proper unique support post arraignment.
Bottom Line:Richard Segal at Right on Track Models produced a beautiful craftsman like replica of the Woodbury Station which will serve as the centerpiece of my Pennsylvania-Reading Seashore Lines layout and I am grateful for his work. It would never have been accomplished without him.
The build did leave a little to be desired. I think the main problem is the material for an N scale model is so thin that it warps significantly when painted on only one side. Hopefully Richard will find a way to correct these issues on future N scale structures. Richard also does outstanding custom builds.