0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I ran the motor for a few seconds and it would start at 1.8 volts and .04 amps. I am going to guess that one of the drive shafts had no play and was forcing the armature against the opposite bearing.
Bart's motor was in perfect shape. To test for the problem that I suggest above take the loco half of the frame that holds the worm gears. Install the motor, and the drives shafts in the frame half. Now take a small screw driver and try to move the worm back and forth. There should be a little back and forth movement. If there isn't I usually press the flywheel on just enough to fix the problem. You can also remove the joint on the end of the shaft and shorten the shaft if there is enough room between it and the bearing next to the worm gear. I'm only talking just enough to create a small back and forth movement.
Hmm . . . in models where worms are not directly coupled to the motor shaft (they are coupled via some sort of universal or a hex-coupling), any play in the worm's shaft should not interfere or affect the play in the motor shaft. The couplings should have enough slop in them to accomplish that. The entire reason for those couplings is to decouple the motor from the worms. The motor bearings should not be subjected to any longitudinal thrust. That thrust shroud only be at the worm bearings. If pushing the worm shaft forward and backwards directly transfers that movement to the motor shaft, then the drive train is not assembled correctly.
Seems that you like to run your models rather fast (not that there is anything wrong with that).
But I 'm still puzzled by the statement you made in your initial post: "Even if I crank up the throttle to around 50 when I start the engine, it still takes forever to get up to speed. I have a smaller layout, with about 30 feet of mainline track, and it may take 2 laps around the layout before it gets up to speed.".That is not how any motor behaves (slwo or fast speed) (unless there is some other problem with the mechanism, like thickened grease). If you set the speed to 50, the model will leap to that speed within a second or two, without any slow momentum like you described. It would not take 60 feet of travel. But again, the motors have been replaced, and the important thing is that you are pleased with the result.
Why my one locomotive behaved so differently is going to be one of those mysteries we’ll probably never be able to solve now!Bart
When I received your motor the first thing I did was measure the flywheels distance from the motor. One was not pressed on far enough. I corrected that problem when I pressed the flywheels on the Kato motor that I sent to you. That's why your loco runs so much better with the Kato motor. Jim