0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Meanwhile, the Trix 0-6-0 can deliver 10-12 cars, but it's going to do it at 100 mph, ...
How about an "Erie Built" ??
Did Atlas acquire the C-Liner tooling? I’d like to see it rereleased.
Quote from: wm3798 on November 25, 2019, 10:42:54 PM...Meanwhile, the Trix 0-6-0 can deliver 10-12 cars, but it's going to do it at 100 mph, and not at all over a long plastic frog... LeeHave you tried a DKS PWM throttle?http://davidksmith.com/modeling/throttle.htm
...Meanwhile, the Trix 0-6-0 can deliver 10-12 cars, but it's going to do it at 100 mph, and not at all over a long plastic frog... Lee
Have you tried a DKS PWM throttle?http://davidksmith.com/modeling/throttle.htmA throttle cannot make up for the Trix 0-6-0's problems.The issue with the Trix 0-6-0 isn't so much the gearing as the pickup. While the motor and gearing are fast, the problem is that the pickup is so shoddy that unless it's running down the track really fast, it will surely stall, and no throttle can fix that. So it does indeed have to run at "100 mph" to keep from stalling.If you connect clip leads from the track directly to the Trix 0-6-0 motor and run it on a good throttle, it can indeed run quite well (although still not as slow as we really want in modern times). But it's a lost cause without tender pickup.
I think Atlas acquired the tooling for both. It would be nice for Atlas to re-release them with modern DCC/sound support, a more accurate nose on the C-Liner (the L-L shell is a wee bit pointy compared to the prototype), and some variants like others mentioned. The C-Liner 5-axle of course would be cool, as would the earlier Erie-Built with the "chop-top" cab and fabricated truck sideframes. If Atlas can make an obscure variant like the SD26 from the SD24, they can probably make the chop-top cabs on the Eries. Walthers produced a re-release of the C-Liner with support for DCC/sound, but only with a specific MDC decoder that has been discontinued. I added ESU Loksound to my Walthers C-Liners but had to hack up the stock light boards to accommodate the decoders. I'm sure Atlas can do whatever mods they did on the FA1/FB1 frame to the C-Liner and Erie-Built frames to make LokSound work.Some other re-releases I'd like to see in modernized form from Atlas:-DL109-FA2/FB2-Low-nose GP18-C636-H-12-44-USRA 0-8-0 (long shot since the L-L tooling is missing or destroyed)From Kato:-J3a Hudson, both streamlined and non-streamlined (maybe with J1 and J2 versions, too?)From Atlas or Rapido:-C424. The tooling for the L-L release is owned by the Canadian company that commissioned them, so Atlas doesn't have it. Atlas is still the logical choice for this loco given the other Centuries they've built, but I think this would also be a nice project for Rapido given the longer lives the C424 and C425 had in Canada.From... BLI or Bachmann, I guess?-RF-16 Sharknose. What, you think I wouldn't ask for an improved re-release of these?
Whatever happened to the old V Line Erie Built shells? I have a couple of those I put on the old Con Cor PA units.