0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
It strikes me that this product may be perfect for flat layouts but if you have any grades it would lose a lot of verisimilitude. That is, unless there's some complicated system for telling the throttle what the grade is and changing the relationship of speed to throttle notch accordingly. I was actually thinking about this the other day and thinking that if the user had a way of telling the throttle what the grade is, it could all be made to work.
This is probably 'way out in left field, but here goes...Last year off eBay I purchased a Heathkit "Electronic Throttle", which is as far from the subject being discussed here as you can get. It's big, heavy (think 1970s era stereo amplifiers), and it has a feature called a "DC Compensation", which reads the current and allows for the engine to slow slightly as it climbs an incline. Is this similar to what you're talking about?I should mention it also has "AC Compensation", which I guess allows for variations in side-rod binding, etc.
However, regardless of how the DC throttle works, the throttle in this thread is DCC. Contemporary DCC decoders do not provide any type of a speed or motor load feedback back to the command station or to the throttle.
Not even being a DCC guy... but one thing I never liked about a lot of handsets I've used is that they just have toomany darn buttons. The pushbutton scroll up/down thing to set the decoder number is ugly, I admit. But I'm nota fan of the keypad either because even though it's easy, it puts 10 more buttons on the throttle.What about a simple dial rotary encoder? You still have an LCD display. You just spin the dial left or right torun the number up or down to what you want, and then push a button. Controls like that are usually speed sensitive,so if you spin the dial faster, the number rolls up faster. Now, you only have one control instead of 10 buttons. Do any DCC throttles work that way?