0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Hi guys,OK - NEW PROBLEM!The factory fought me when I tried to have prototypical 30" diameter wheels on the Turbo. But they grudgingly put them on.Now they have illustrated the problem. See the image attached. The gears are basically touching the rails. They will certainly hit crossings and frogs. The factory wants to increase the wheel diameter to 36". To make the train look correct, it means we need to increase all the wheels to 36".Would that be considered acceptable in N scale? I'm not keen on increasing the wheel diameter, but I'm not seeing any way out of this.Your input would be appreciated.Thanks,Jason
OK - NEW PROBLEM!The factory fought me when I tried to have prototypical 30" diameter wheels on the Turbo. But they grudgingly put them on.The gears are basically touching the rails. They will certainly hit crossings and frogs. The factory wants to increase the wheel diameter to 36". To make the train look correct, it means we need to increase all the wheels to 36".Would that be considered acceptable in N scale? I'm not keen on increasing the wheel diameter, but I'm not seeing any way out of this.Your input would be appreciated.
Man, those things really give new meaning to "bloody nose scheme."
John.Great illustration. Thanks for posting.The tentative observation I have is.....What you have show in a snapshot of something new.At present, you have clearly show that you could remove material.But assuming the amount you indicated were removed....... over time, those edges will wear a bit.I would think there might be a danger of eventually cogging without the extra material.
@rapidotrains , Since the power transfer of a involute tooth spur gear is transferred to the next tooth just before the first tooth no longer contacts its mating tooth, reducing the OD of the axle gear should have absolutely no ill effect on the gear set. See below the red points of contact exist at the same time.After you look at your mesh there may be some OD reduction available: (Attachment Link) If you are tooling new gears for these axles anyway that is what I would look into.