Hey Atlas...

[bbussey]

Not really.  The HO model is of a specific prototype that is very appropriate for New Haven modelers.  Why wouldn't I want to see that model in N?

[cjm413]

Not really.  The HO model is of a specific prototype that is very appropriate for New Haven modelers.  Why wouldn't I want to see that model in N?

A N scale version of the former Branchline 50' plug door car seems like a logical choice, whether to use as-is or as a starting point for a 40' FGE RBL.

[OldEastRR]

Not really.  The HO model is of a specific prototype that is very appropriate for New Haven modelers.  Why wouldn't I want to see that model in N?

Well, review your e-mail to me of 5/18/14. Anyway, maybe more people are on board now with making this car.

[daniel_leavitt2000]

As long as we are Asking atlas to build cars off items acquired from Branchline in HO....

Berwick

[cjm413]

As long as we are Asking atlas to build cars off items acquired from Branchline in HO....

Berwick

Different mold inserts to cover multiple doors would be nice

[Allentown Hump]

Im just going to leave this hear.

[Ed Kapuscinski]

I'd be in for one. But only if they did the matching GP10s to go along with them.

[OldEastRR]

Ed: Why is John Goodman's face in your icon box?

[Ed Kapuscinski]

Lol, because I haven't been hitting the gym religiously like I should be.

[Chris333]

Ed: Why is John Goodman's face in your icon box?

I though it was Seth Rogen 

[bbussey]

Well, review your e-mail to me of 5/18/14. Anyway, maybe more people are on board now with making this car.

I never said I didn't want to see a 40' FGE plug door boxcar in N.  I said it wasn't practical for a manufacturer to tool it because it's a one-prototype car.  That said, I'd rather see that prototype appear in N than see the Trainman model "upgraded" since it is not based on a valid prototype.  There's no change in my original position.

[bbussey]

I'd be in for one. But only if they did the matching GP10s to go along with them.

They were paired with non-dynamic SD38 units here.

[davefoxx]

I wasn't going to respond to this thread, until I received an email with the following announcement from Atlas today.

http://www.atlasrr.com/HOLoco/hou3336.htm?utm_source=ISMax&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=0416ASMC

Bring SCL U36B #1776 in the bicentennial scheme to N scale, please!

DFF

[cjm413]

They were paired with non-dynamic SD38 units here.

SD38/39/40 with scale-width hoods

[sirenwerks]

I think next time I'll just post my wish and then lock the topic, and let everyone else do their own thing in their own topic...      The schizophrenic free for all was not what I was hoping for.