Author Topic: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points / servo mechanism redesign  (Read 8798 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

bbussey

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9391
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +6191
    • www.bbussey.net
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #15 on: September 15, 2013, 02:26:42 PM »
0
I have to throw two symmetrical sets of points simultaneously, which is why the pivot points are horizontal and perpendicular to the throw bar.  For the double crossover, there is one servo mechanism at each end.  Both mechanisms are controlled with one DPDT momentary (on)/off/(on) toggle, with one "on" being the straight route for all four points and the other "on" being the diverging (crossover) route for all four points.  Since you operationally can't have only one set of points thrown and have an unobstructed path, it makes sense to control all four sets of points with one toggle.  I have six of these to get working.



« Last Edit: September 15, 2013, 02:28:27 PM by bbussey »
Bryan Busséy
NHRHTA #2246
NSE #1117
www.bbussey.net
Bridgeport & New London in N scale


jdcolombo

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 2399
  • Respect: +1213
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #16 on: September 15, 2013, 02:48:25 PM »
0
Not to get us too far off the original thread, but is there a particular reason you are trying to do this mechanically, instead of electrically?  Electrically, it is fairly trivial to set up a diode matrix to run 4 switch machines at once.  Two servos are much cheaper than 4 Tortoises, of course, but I'm not sure I see an advantage to using two mechanical linkages instead of 4 when electrical control is so easy to set up.  Of course, using 4 Tortoises won't solve a wire flex problem, but I was just curious why you went this route instead of a mechanically simpler (though electrically somewhat more complex) route.

John C.

bbussey

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9391
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +6191
    • www.bbussey.net
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #17 on: September 15, 2013, 04:01:19 PM »
0
Because there is no room for Tortoises and they are too expensive for this application.  It's not just one double crossover — it's a concentration of four doubles and two singles, all packed tightly together.  It makes far more sense to develop a small-footprint servo mechanism incorporating the Tam Valley controller.  The advantage is the lower cost and more straightforward electrical arrangement; the necessity is that the compact footprint of the mechanism fits directly and completely underneath the crossover end with no overhang.  With 1-1/8" between all the track centers and seven tracks deep and 20 points to throw, Tortoises are not a viable option.  And one mechanism, which throws two points, costs less than one discounted Tortoise.

I suppose it is possible to devise a way to have one Tortoise throw two symmetrical sets of points.  But using the Tam Valley controller and a servo serves a number of purposes without pushing the cost into orbit.
Bryan Busséy
NHRHTA #2246
NSE #1117
www.bbussey.net
Bridgeport & New London in N scale


Sokramiketes

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 5423
  • Better modeling through peer pressure...
  • Respect: +2195
    • Modutrak
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #18 on: September 15, 2013, 04:08:05 PM »
0
I'd go with cranks and boden wire to move your motor of choice out from under that mess entirely!

garethashenden

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 2352
  • Respect: +1854
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #19 on: September 15, 2013, 04:17:58 PM »
0
Tortoises have a thingy by which the fulcrum of the mechanism can be adjusted. As the wire rises it goes through a hole in a piece of plastic. This piece of plastic can slide up and down as needed. If it is high up the wire can't move very far but if it is low down it multiplies the distance the wire moves. The wire at the top of the motor can move almost twice as far as the motor itself actually moves it. This allows for adjustment if the point blades aren't moving far enough. I think you should look into something like this, some sort of fulcrum near the servo which can increase the throw/power of the servo.
The green crossbar in this image is what I'm talking about:
« Last Edit: September 15, 2013, 04:20:34 PM by garethashenden »

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #20 on: September 15, 2013, 04:41:32 PM »
0
I'd endorse Mike's recommendation to go with cranks. These can be connected to all manner of linkages that could potentially allow you to operate all four switches of the double crossovers with one servo (assuming it has the torque).

Van Horne

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 168
  • Respect: +24
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #21 on: September 15, 2013, 04:43:35 PM »
0
The issue here can't be solved by moving the fulcrum point.  Blue Point controllers have the same adjustment mechanism.  While moving the fulcrum point down increases the throw at the top, it actually exacerbates the flexibility problem with the actuating wire.  It can turn 1 3/4 inches of unsupported wire into 2 3/4 inches.  This is based on sad personal experience with these solid-point turnouts!

David

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #22 on: September 15, 2013, 05:00:48 PM »
0
Here's a conceptual illustration of an assembly of linkages that could move all four points with one motor drive, which would be connected to the center rocker arm. Track, roadbed and motor drive omitted for clarity.

« Last Edit: September 15, 2013, 05:08:00 PM by David K. Smith »

bbussey

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9391
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +6191
    • www.bbussey.net
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #23 on: September 15, 2013, 05:02:50 PM »
0
I'd go with cranks and boden wire to move your motor of choice out from under that mess entirely!

I'd endorse Mike's recommendation to go with cranks. These can be connected to all manner of linkages that could potentially allow you to operate all four switches of the double crossovers with one servo (assuming it has the torque).

Gentlemen, I'm open to suggestions as this is not my area of expertise.  Here is a reduced version of the template:



Any ideas on how to throw all four points simultaneously would be welcome.  If from one servo, all the better.  I can upgrade to servos with greater torque if necessary.  The current servos won't be wasted, as they can be used on regular turnouts elsewhere, and any servo can be powered with the Tam Valley controller.
Bryan Busséy
NHRHTA #2246
NSE #1117
www.bbussey.net
Bridgeport & New London in N scale


bbussey

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9391
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +6191
    • www.bbussey.net
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #24 on: September 15, 2013, 05:06:28 PM »
0
Here's a conceptual illustration of an assembly of linkages that could move all four points with one motor drive, which would be connected to the center rocker arm. Track and motor drive omitted for clarity.

I understand the servo would drive the rocker arm in the diagram.  I'm not comprehending how the push/pull of the linkages affects the four points so that each of them operate symmetrically to the other three.
Bryan Busséy
NHRHTA #2246
NSE #1117
www.bbussey.net
Bridgeport & New London in N scale


dwyaneward

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 47
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +2
    • http://kdrail.blogspot.com/
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #25 on: September 15, 2013, 05:06:34 PM »
0
A HO buddy of mine show me how to relieve the tension of the points of a fast track turnout . He remove a small portion of lower flange each side of each point rail toward the points after the solder point(hinge point).
Dwyane Ward | Fairview, TX.
-------------------------------------
http://kdrail.blogspot.com/

DKS

  • The Pitt
  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 13424
  • Respect: +7027
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #26 on: September 15, 2013, 05:10:41 PM »
0
I understand the servo would drive the rocker arm in the diagram.  I'm not comprehending how the push/pull of the linkages affects the four points so that each of them operate symmetrically to the other three.

The vertical tubes would pass through the roadbed. The wire rods would engage the throwbars. Underneath, the switch linkages are connected in pairs such that movement tangentially to the throwbars would actuate them in opposite directions (thus, symmetrically).

EDIT: Here's a revised illustration that will hopefully make the movements clear. The green arrows indicate linkage movements; red arrows indicate the throwbar movements. The top illustration shows the route being set for the straight tracks; the lower shows the route being set for the crossover tracks.



There would almost certainly be a need for some means of linkage adjustment; this is just a conceptual illustration.
« Last Edit: September 15, 2013, 05:27:32 PM by David K. Smith »

bbussey

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 9391
  • Gender: Male
  • Respect: +6191
    • www.bbussey.net
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #27 on: September 15, 2013, 05:41:12 PM »
0
Okay, I've got it now.  I'll start working on a redesign now.
Bryan Busséy
NHRHTA #2246
NSE #1117
www.bbussey.net
Bridgeport & New London in N scale


robert3985

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 3599
  • Respect: +1994
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #28 on: September 15, 2013, 06:18:51 PM »
0
FWIW (not much) I have been using hinged points in all of my proto:87-based turnouts, including a crossover on a grade sandwiched between two curves.  I've been running very challenging trains through them - some with mid and rear-train helpers - and I've yet to have a derailment or other issue that I can attribute to the hinge.

I have tried to take great care to make sure that the points have almost no resistance to motion, and I've actually downsized the Tortoise wire from .025" to .019" to minimize stress on the point/throwbar joint, which is a much bigger point of failure than the hinge, IMHO (especially if they require so much force to actuate).  I wouldn't be so reluctant to try hinged points.


-gfh

I completely agree with Gary on his points (pun intended).  I have never had a failure at the hinges and my latest turnouts (14 of 'em) all have the Proto87 Stores hinges on Andy's tri-planed points.  I don't run "long" trains as my sidings limit my train length to 9' 7.5" (30 40ft cars, a Big Boy and caboose), but I have zero derailments due to track problems. 

In my long past of building, testing, installing and operating N-scale hand built turnouts, the main place that problems occur is at the closure points.

When I first started out soldering 'em up in the late 70's, I noticed the points were really stiff on my first couple of builds.  This was because my PCB ties (from Railcraft) had a miniscule burr on some of the edges caused by the shearing process.  I got rid of the stiffness by making sure I took a file to "break" the sharp edge just enough to get rid of that burr before cutting the 1' pieces into shorter ties.  I also lube the tops of any ties the closure points slide across with either graphite, soft pencil lead, or Neolube.

After all that, some of my points weren't moving enough to operate properly and the problem wasn't with the points or my Tortoises or the stiffness of the actuating wire.  The problem was due to either the hole for the actuating wire under the throwbar not being centered (so the actuating wire would come in contact with the side of the hole and the tip wouldn't move enough to close the points in one direction), or the Tortoise underneath wasn't centered side to side on its mounting plate...and once again, the actuating wire was contacting one side of the clearance hole drilled through my 1" splined Masonite subroadbed before the points were closed in one direction up above.

Nowadays, when I mount my Tortoises, I make sure the actuating wire is centered on the Tortoise (and that the wire is about 1/4" longer than it needs to be).  Then, I "fish" the wire up through the hole under the throwbar and through the hole drilled in the center of the throwbar...then I clamp a small, smooth-jawed hemostat on it so the Tortoise/wire combo won't fall, mix up some 5 min Epoxy and spread it on the 1/8" thick aircraft quality plywood mounting plate (which the Tortoise is already screwed to) and press the Tortoise assembly against the underside of my subroadbed.  This gives me a little time to make sure everything is properly aligned (which is really important) particularly that the closure points on the turnout are centered and not touching either stock rail.

Then, I just hold it in place while the epoxy cures, which is easy for me to do with open benchwork...doing it all from above.  In the past when I've had to change trackwork when the scenery was in, I didn't have the luxury of doing it from above, so I'd enlist one of my sons to crawl around under the benchwork and position the new Tortoise in relation to the new turnout above. To make sure the points were centered,  I would guide the installation from up top...a definite two-man operation.

After I check to make sure the points are moving properly, I take a cut-off wheel in my Dremel and cut the actuating wire that's protruding out of the top of the PCB throwbar so only about 1/32" is sticking up.

If I were you, I'd check to make sure the closure points were not binding on any burrs on the edges of any PCB ties they're resting on, and that the PCB throwbar isn't doing the same from any burrs that might be on its edges.  De-soldering the PCB throwbars and de-burring the corners isn't too difficult, and would also allow you to make sure the PCB ties under the closure point (since you can move the point rails from side to side now that they're detached from the PCB throwbar) are de-burred also. 

If all of this doesn't work, then the last thing to do is to remove a bit of the copper cladding from your throwbar where it rubs on the underside of the stock rails.  That should loosen it up enough so that your closure points move freely and aren't "stiff".  Do that with a fine sanding wheel on your Dremel or using a square fine jeweler's file.  Remember to "lube" this area with graphite, soft pencil lead or Neolube.

Hmmm...just to renumerate, these four things should do the trick for you without you having to hinge your points.  (1) Make a stiffer actuating wire, (2) Make sure your actuating wire isn't hitting the sides of your under-turnout clearance hole by confirming that when the actuating wire is centered on your Tortoise, it holds the points exactly midway between each stock rail, (3) Make sure the corners of your PCB ties are totally de-burred under your closure points...and (4) Make sure your PCB throwbar is also de-burred and, if necessary, remove an RCH of copper cladding from where it rubs on the undersides of your stock rails, and lube it.

If that doesn't do the trick...then you'll know you've transitioned into Bizarro World.

[EDIT]  Okay...no Tortoises for your application...however the centering protocol is still valid as well how to ensure your points will move freely by de-burring your PCB ties and lubing them.  By the way, lovely complicated trackwork!  Once you get it de-bugged, and all is working well, it'll bring a big ol' smile to your face!
« Last Edit: September 15, 2013, 06:37:21 PM by robert3985 »

robert3985

  • Crew
  • *
  • Posts: 3599
  • Respect: +1994
Re: Stiffness of Fast Track crossover points
« Reply #29 on: September 15, 2013, 06:29:46 PM »
0
The vertical tubes would pass through the roadbed. The wire rods would engage the throwbars. Underneath, the switch linkages are connected in pairs such that movement tangentially to the throwbars would actuate them in opposite directions (thus, symmetrically).

EDIT: Here's a revised illustration that will hopefully make the movements clear. The green arrows indicate linkage movements; red arrows indicate the throwbar movements. The top illustration shows the route being set for the straight tracks; the lower shows the route being set for the crossover tracks.



There would almost certainly be a need for some means of linkage adjustment; this is just a conceptual illustration.

DKS...you just draw that up like SHAZZAM and there it is???  I'm impressed!