0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I'd go with cranks and boden wire to move your motor of choice out from under that mess entirely!
I'd endorse Mike's recommendation to go with cranks. These can be connected to all manner of linkages that could potentially allow you to operate all four switches of the double crossovers with one servo (assuming it has the torque).
Here's a conceptual illustration of an assembly of linkages that could move all four points with one motor drive, which would be connected to the center rocker arm. Track and motor drive omitted for clarity.
I understand the servo would drive the rocker arm in the diagram. I'm not comprehending how the push/pull of the linkages affects the four points so that each of them operate symmetrically to the other three.
FWIW (not much) I have been using hinged points in all of my proto:87-based turnouts, including a crossover on a grade sandwiched between two curves. I've been running very challenging trains through them - some with mid and rear-train helpers - and I've yet to have a derailment or other issue that I can attribute to the hinge.I have tried to take great care to make sure that the points have almost no resistance to motion, and I've actually downsized the Tortoise wire from .025" to .019" to minimize stress on the point/throwbar joint, which is a much bigger point of failure than the hinge, IMHO (especially if they require so much force to actuate). I wouldn't be so reluctant to try hinged points.-gfh
The vertical tubes would pass through the roadbed. The wire rods would engage the throwbars. Underneath, the switch linkages are connected in pairs such that movement tangentially to the throwbars would actuate them in opposite directions (thus, symmetrically).EDIT: Here's a revised illustration that will hopefully make the movements clear. The green arrows indicate linkage movements; red arrows indicate the throwbar movements. The top illustration shows the route being set for the straight tracks; the lower shows the route being set for the crossover tracks.There would almost certainly be a need for some means of linkage adjustment; this is just a conceptual illustration.