0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
At what price would you stay then............? Bachmann's MSRP vs Kato's MAP price.....? We are talking apples to oranges.......
and as you said; the Bachmann motor runs well enough.
3-pole or 5-pole. Those Bachmann GP7's ran well for me. Nice slow speed operation. Yeah, maybe the decoder is creating much of that, but still, if it runs well, it runs well.
I want to go to DCC in the future (and I will), but at the moment that would mean big bucks for me (a large fleet of locos). It would be really cool if DCC "cures" the low speed performance of modern 3 pole motors.Mark
I want to go to DCC in the future (and I will), but at the moment that would mean big bucks for me (a large fleet of locos). It would be really cool if DCC "cures" the low speed performance of modern 3 pole motors.
Yes there is a "remediation" for the 3 pole cogging at low speed. In DCC you have BEMF, or "Speed Stabilization", I can have my little 44T crawl ties (with a DZ143MO (IIRC)). http://www.tonystrains.com/technews/introto_bemf_pid.htmIt's not bulletproof but it gets the job done.The S.
I was gonna mention that as well, but I was driving! BEMF is very nice and in some situations acts like a "virtual flywheel" for motors sans flywheels.
Anti dynamic braking . ...... Dynamic Momentum ?
It would be really cool if DCC "cures" the low speed performance of modern 3 pole motors.
after re-reading this and having another reasonI found myself in my basement watching a b-mann 44 tonner.at slow speeds, it cogs.so far I do not see that bachmann has cleared the'as good as' level even with the DCC decoder.it cogs using DCC. it cogs using DC.v
I witnessed this. It cogs less with DCC but still COGS.I understand that the Bmann decoder is a decoder "lite" and I assume has no "BEMF".Mark