I guess the comments by Rick Balassaitis: ... But IF "Alhoop's" comment was directed at putting my
layout "in the dustbin of history", I would consider that rude and I would take issue not with the comment
but rather the attitude it portrays. The internet seems gives us an anonymity that allows us to make
comments that would be insulting in person. I am a member of a railroad historical society and have
watched some folks' acid comments drive folks from the forum that have had much to contribute.
I also belong to a town oriented forum that is totally out of control and dominated by a few
that have to comment on everything. I think Railwire's constituency seem to consistently be
polite and helpful. I guess the success of a forum is due to both the membership and the
moderator's efforts to keep it under control.
.................
deserve an answer.
I congratulate Rick on getting his article published
in N-Scale magazine. If my comment about the dustbin
of history offended him so be it. That was and is my
opinion.
Here are some reasons why:
1 Model Railroader Jan 1977 'Slo-mo-shun switch motor '
http://s1110.photobucket.com/albums/h458/alhoop1/?action=view¤t=Photo5.jpgI built several of these to control turnouts and used one to drive this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qZ6B9VbAPY 2 Model Railroader Dec 1979 'Scratchbuild a signal bridge.'
http://s1110.photobucket.com/albums/h458/alhoop1/?action=view¤t=logic006.jpg3 Model railroader Sep 1982 'An operating windmill'
http://s1110.photobucket.com/albums/h458/alhoop1/?action=view¤t=windmill.jpg4 Model Railroader Jul 1989 'Build a working N-scale crosing signal '
http://s1110.photobucket.com/albums/h458/alhoop1/?action=view¤t=crosssig.mp4I built all four of these -some up to 25 years after publication
and could not name any layout photos in any issue.
They are relegated to my dustbin.
5 Here is one of mine, N-Scale magazine Nov/Dec 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnnVgAqLgBAAs can be seen I appear in the movie so am not really anonymous.
As to my comment that todays modeler had rather drool than build,
Model Railroader didn't think there would be any interest in this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeyjJu1iwh0yet they will devote part of several upcoming issues to building yet another 4 by 8 layout.
So - no apology unless one is owed to me.
Al Hooper