Being an average is taking more than one car into account, I see the answer would depend on the consist makeup and the period being modeled.
Steam era, mainly 40' and smaller if moving coal or ore. Transitional era, 50' become more prevalent. Sixty footers dominated the 60's-70's. Modern era run a gamut from 50' to 89'. Specially true with unit trains. Once you decide the consist makeup, you can easily get the average length with the # of cars in the consist.