I'm a bit late to the show, but, I am in the process of replacing most of my cars' wheelsets with metal wheelsets...and it's expensive...especially if you've got a couple of thousand cars in your roster.
I agree with Peter (
@peteski ) that I don't notice any difference whatsoever in operation and/or reliability between metal wheelsets and one-piece plastic wheelsets. I converted all of my Kadee/MTL trucked cars long ago to the original low-profile MTL wheelsets, with really low-profile flanges and they worked GREAT, and looked much better too, even though the treads weren't metallic, it really wasn't that noticeable during operation and just running in circles.
However, from an appearance standpoint and in N-scale model photography, the metal wheelsets look a LOT better...especially narrow-tired wheelsets, and when I go to the effort to superdetail or scratchbuild a car, I use narrow-tread low profile wheelsets..just because they look a whole lot better.
Since my maximum length train is 9' 7.5" long (non-priority freights that get switched on to center sidings to allow priority trains to pass) with my priority trains being maybe a foot longer, I'm not too concerned about rolling resistance since Delrin to Delrin vs Metal to Delrin bearing surfaces don't seem noticeably different with my train lengths, and Delrin tread surfaces vs Brass tread surfaces also (in my experience) have no noticeable difference.
I like and use exclusively FVM narrow-tread (semi-prototypical) wheelsets with various axle lengths. The two axle lengths I use are .540" and .553" mostly for MT trucks and IMR trucks.
Since I hand-lay ALL of my turnouts to "tight" clearances, I don't have any problems whatsoever with narrow wheelsets derailing because of too-wide Check-gauge, or too-wide guard rail clearances, which means I don't need any "forgiveness" in my wheelsets because of out-of-gauge turnouts or track.
From an appearance stand-point, I prefer the outer wheel profile of the FVM wheelsets, particularly because of the narrow division between the curved face and the wheel tread. The inside profiles of FVM wheels are just straight, which isn't prototypical, but, I'm not looking at the insides of the wheelsets at all when they're on cars that are coupled up and running. If the majority of time I looked at my cars upside down in a foam work cradle, then it might make a difference. I might make an exception for tank cars, which I have a bunch of.
HOWEVER, it's just my preference as ESM metal wheelsets' outer wheel profile is also pretty close to prototype, but with much more/thicker surface at the division between the curved face and the wheel tread than the FVM wheels. Both are correct. I looked at photos of prototype wheel faces and both thick and thin divisions between the curved face and tread are visible. I learned that as the wheels wear, this area of the wheel gets thinner and thinner, with new wheels being thick, old wheels being thin.
So, it's just personal preference between the appearance of both wheelsets, with a mix of both probably being most prototypical. However, ESM has a correct inner surface wheel profile if that's important to you. Also, it appears to me that the narrow-tread FVM wheels tread is thinner than ESM...which is a big plus IMO for FVM wheels.
From an appearance standpoint another good choice is IMR metal wheelsets, which come in both MTL (.537") and IMR (.553") compatible length axles (which includes other truck sideframes also). I haven't seen these in the flesh, but photos look as if the inner surface is straight, and the outer surface profile is somewhere between the FVM and ESM wheelsets' profiles. IMR also says their wheelsets are "nickel plated", then say the newest run has a "...dull, blackened appearance to be more realistic without the immediate need for weathering." When looking at photos, it appears the treads are still bright & shiny...maybe they're referring to only the inner & outer wheel surfaces & not the tread...maybe. IMR also offers a "High Detail Wheels" package of 12 that includes prototypical inside and outside wheel profiles in only 12 packs, but the same price as their plain wheelset 12 packs.
The only drawback that I've had is because the FVM wheelsets, as well as the other brands, are composed of multiple parts, with one wheel having an insulating center, sometimes these either get out of gauge, or disassemble. In 100 packs, the FVM wheelsets so far have had at least two wheelsets that were disassembled, which I was able to put back together. Also, when installing into truck sideframes, push on the non-insulated wheel as it is by far sturdier than the insulated wheel.
I'd think that using this caution while assembling is valid for the other brands also.
The other brand that looks good is 36" metal wheelsets from Tangent Scale Models. I appears they only come in 36" diameter and MTL compatible .537" axle lengths, however, making them inappropriate for the majority of N-scale freight cars from a diameter standpoint. BUT, if you want good-looking, correct surface profiles inside & outside, 36" wheelsets, these definitely are an excellent option.
Since a lot of us are converting to metal wheelsets for one reason or another, and many of us have large rosters of cars to convert, price is an important aspect to explore.
Since all of these wheelsets aren't available at any single online store, I'll quote the best prices I found online from various sources, which are: Midwest Model RR, N Scale Supply, Scale Trains, Spring Creek Model Trains
(1) - Tangent Scale Models N-scale 36" dia. 0.537" axle length: $88.18/100 or $3.53 per car(2) - Fox Valley Models N-scale 33"/36" dia. 0.540"/0.553" axle lengths: $75.99/100 or $3.04 per car(3) - Eastern Seaboard Models 33"/36" dia. 0.540"/0.553" axle lengths: $52.00/60 or $3.47 per car(4) - Eastern Seaboard Models 28" dia. 0.540" axle length: $13.82/12 or $4.61 per car(5) - Intermountain Railway 33"/36" dia. 0.537"/0.554" axle lengths: $116.00/100 or $4.64 per car(6) - Intermountain Railway 33"/36" dia. 0.537"/0.554" axle lengths - High Detail Wheelsets: $15.96/12 or $5.32 per carIf you're not concerned about inside prototype wheel profiles, then FVM wheelsets are significantly cheaper than any of the others.
If you ARE concerned about inside prototype wheel profiles, and are okay with the outside wheel profile representing a newly applied wheel, then ESM 30" and 36" wheelsets are the best buy.
If you want a more worn outside wheel profile and a proper inside wheel surface profile in a 36" wheel, then Tangent Scale Models wheelsets are it...but, they're a few cents per car more than ESM.
If you need 28" wheelsets, then ESM is your only choice only in 12 packs and for $1.10 more per car than the next most expensive 33"/36" wheelsets.
If, for some reason, your LHS only stocks IMR 33"/36" N-scale wheelsets, plan to pay a couple of cents more per car than the expensive ESM 28" wheelsets.
And finally, if you have money to burn and/or IMR "High Detail Wheels" 33"/36" wheelsets are all you can find in your neck of the woods, you'll have some excellent-looking wheelsets, but,
for $5.32 per car!!I am pretty sure there is very little (if any) difference in quality between these brands...just differences in inner & outer wheel profiles and in the tread width. From a purely operational standpoint the FVM "standard" wheelset is significantly the lowest price (as well as the semi-scale narrow-tread version) and equipping 100 cars with the FVM's will save you $43.00 over the next least expensive ESM's.
Using FVM's instead of IMR 33"/36" "High Detail Wheels" to equip 100 cars, will save you a whopping $228.00!!
Now that you're informed Bob (
@Bob )...and anybody else, now you'll be able to make a more informed metal wheel decision for your N-scale car roster.
Cheerio!
Bob Gilmore