Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Home
Help
Login
Register
TheRailwire
»
General Discussion
»
Layout Engineering Reports
»
The Warren Piece
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Down
Author
Topic: The Warren Piece (Read 966 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
The Warren Piece
«
on:
October 25, 2026, 11:12:52 AM »
+4
So with all my Ttrak modules (now up to
I've already done there's a glaring 'don't have'..... I 'don't have' any curves.
So, as I'm modeling the Salamanca Branch (Oil City, PA - Olean NY) there are a couple inspirations for 90-degree (or close to it) curves.
The favorite is in my hometown, Warren, PA, where the 2-track main line crosses the Allegheny River on a truss bridge, and makes an immediate 90-degree curve to the west in the middle of the west end of the town. And on the outside of the curve, the location of the original two-story passenger station. The track has since been reduced to one track, the station was on the National Register but demolished in 1986, the brick REA Express building survives as well as the 'original wing' of Struthers Wells (now Grand Valley Machine) on the inside of the curve. It's been modernized on roof and windows but basically same building.
It's a pretty wide curve. So I started looking at Ttrak wide curve specs, and our preference for them at shows. Looks like it could work, but no drawings of the station and no clues left on the ground, and the Historical Society came up empty. I checked my railfan network for idea, and BINGO, Nick sent me a copy of the ones he had from PRRTHS, two floor plans and a front elevation. I could work from that, so last summer I started cutting up plywood and planning on the big scratchbuild.
So here was the start, and this was actually a 'standby' module at Altoona that wasn't needed. The 'trick' on this is getting rid of those darn concrete ties. This was split, part in a platform and part open track, so the way to tie it in is use a tiny chunk of the Kato wide curves as an adapter on both ends, and then transition to Peco C55 in the middle. I paint ties gray, paint the rail, and then hit the ties with tie weathering solution, my standard. The Peco track is on cork, shimmed .020 as necessary for transition.
So here's the way it looked this summer:
Here's the front elevation on it, along with an E8 and passenger car for scale. Last train in 1965 was an E8 and 3 cars Harrisburg - Erie, PA. Round thing is a footprint of the water tank.
Here's the station, which I rode out of in 1960 and 1964 as a kid. Note the round windows and all those curved roof supports. Painted brick.
So here we go, and I'm starting this thread now that the process is well along, but I've documented it going forward.
Logged
peteski
Crew
Posts: 35436
Gender:
Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
Respect:
+6696
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #1 on:
October 25, 2026, 11:32:20 AM »
+1
And I thought this was a play on words about "War And Peace" novel.
Logged
. . . 42 . . .
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #2 on:
October 25, 2026, 11:35:58 AM »
+5
Here's the Sanborne map of the immediate station area. And the parallel street behind it. There was a hotel, two restaurants, etc. Those are all gone now.
But the street - labelled as "Chestnut St. E" was a trolley right of way. Brick street. Still there today. And the rail is still in it, when the trolleys left about 1938.
The "Revere Hotel" became the Riverside, turned into a true dump, and burned to the ground in 2002.
View from the other angle:
In the 70's, adjacent Struthers was booming, the station was empty, and it turned into a parking lot. The 'best spots' were under the roof overhang, particularly in winter.
Penn Central priced the building and property for over $50K in 1985, with a leaking roof, no heating system, severely deteriorated. Typical strategy for PC real estate after overvaluing everything they owned in terms of real estate. No takers, ended up getting buldozed despite lower offers. Empty lot today.
«
Last Edit: October 25, 2026, 11:48:32 AM by randgust
»
Logged
Chris333
Crew
Posts: 19707
Respect:
+6987
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #3 on:
October 25, 2026, 11:50:04 AM »
0
I had a 77' Thunderbird with fog lights just like in the photo
Logged
peteski
Crew
Posts: 35436
Gender:
Honorary Resident Curmudgeon
Respect:
+6696
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #4 on:
October 25, 2026, 11:53:26 AM »
0
Quote from: randgust on October 25, 2026, 11:35:58 AM
View from the other angle:
That will make a nice scene for the module. The car featured prominently in the foreground made me smile. Looks like a '77 Ford T-Bird I used to own. With all the vehicles now available from Showcase Miniatures you could probably recreate that photo almost exactly.
Logged
. . . 42 . . .
Chris333
Crew
Posts: 19707
Respect:
+6987
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #5 on:
October 25, 2026, 11:59:41 AM »
0
https://www.showcaseminiatures.net/madaboutcars/n_scale/J16N.html
Logged
OldEastRR
Crew
Posts: 3803
Gender:
Respect:
+518
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #6 on:
October 26, 2026, 03:33:27 AM »
0
Looking at Google maps it seems Chestnut St is mis-labelled, as that road is SW of the tracks and River bridgehead.
Logged
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #7 on:
October 26, 2026, 07:31:39 AM »
0
Chestnut st and chestnut street ‘east’ (E) is the answer. The trolley street is just barely a public street today with no name. In 1922 it was named. There are still rails in the mud and bricks.
That Sanborne map is the only time I've ever found a name on that 15' wide strip of 'street'. It's no longer a public street and was folded into the old station parcel.
«
Last Edit: October 26, 2026, 09:55:11 AM by randgust
»
Logged
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #8 on:
October 26, 2026, 10:07:35 AM »
+3
So here's the breakthrough - although lots of photos were discovered, finding the drawings was the breakthrough. I reversed them in Photoshop to make black on white and converted them to JPG's. With known dimensions on the floor plan, the side elevation was resized and both were printed to scale.
And there were evolutionary changes that are model sensitive. It was built in about 1861, red brick, smaller overhangs, cupola on top. And the floor plan of the time was to completely separate men and women waiting rooms, hence the two-sided design. The upstairs has remained a mystery, it was overhauled to move the stairway inside at an unknown date and open a hallway between the two waiting rooms, dimensions unchanged. The building was lengthened and platform roofs expanded.
At some point the women's waiting room appeared to be closed and the chimney removed. Some decorative woodwork was removed.
I'm modeling the 1920's so getting it 'right' is still some guesswork on what was when. But that 1922 Sanborne map agrees with the updated dimensions.
Color postcards from the 1890's also show it was painted in a buff/yellow buff color, and that's another issue. But not brick. By the 60's the upstairs was closed, and it was seeing 2 trains a day, deteriorating until the last train left in 1965. PC abandoned it, tried to sell it, failed, demolished 1986 as a hazard.
The first problem was all those windows. Turns out that the Tichy small round top windows are the right width, and if spliced, could be made so close as to be acceptable. So by merging and splicing a total of 72 individual windows into assemblies, that was the first major step.
«
Last Edit: October 26, 2026, 10:16:07 AM by randgust
»
Logged
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #9 on:
October 27, 2026, 11:32:06 AM »
0
I'll put this shot up because it's 'fun' and there's planning deep in here as well.
I took this shot in 1975, one of my local favorites, the daily PC train from Warren to Ridgway, PA, in fall.
10 years after the last passenger train left, but some important details. First, the code lines, forgot about those..... Second, note that the brick passenger platform is right level to the top of rail, but set back to tie edge, and there is a concrete or stone edge piece. Oddly enough, I have a 1960 shot that shows a timber platform completely over the outer track that must have been removed. But the trick is that the entire building has to be raised to railhead level.
Also, this was a Kodachrome slide I had made into a print and scanned. Note how 'yellow' the building is, compare this with the other color shot from about the same era. So what color was it? I'm leaning toward the lighter phase. Also note the roof, which was metal, but looks like seamed asphalt, I think it was copper, and looked quite black. Note the other color shot shows it partially peeled back. The 'lower third' of the building was a darker color, I'm guessing standard PRR brown, by the time I'm seeing color shots it's just 'darker' on the bottom of the posts and the bottom third of the lower story walls.
Also notice that the top roof overhang is not consistent. The center gable overhang comes out a lot farther than the main building overhang, maybe by about 18 inches or more.
One of the things that drives me crazy about this building is that due to that wide overhang on the bottom the entire bottom half of all the later photos just disappears into darkness. I have excellent black and white photos in the National Historic Register nomination, but no color.
Still one of my best PC era shots
«
Last Edit: October 27, 2026, 11:56:23 AM by randgust
»
Logged
wm3798
Crew
Posts: 16593
Gender:
I like models. She likes antiques. Perfect!
Respect:
+7525
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #10 on:
October 27, 2026, 02:30:46 PM »
0
Looks like your model will be spot on.
Love the source material. That's a great photo. It would be fun to clean up digitally. Looks like an old instamatic silk print, am I right?
Lee
Logged
Rockin' It Old School
Lee Weldon
www.wmrywesternlines.net
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #11 on:
October 28, 2026, 08:28:22 AM »
+3
Well, that was a Kodachrome slide that I now can't find, converted to a print, converted to a scan.... Lucky I have it at all after 51 years.
Meanwhile, back at the model. I used to be a firm believer in H&R brick sheeting, did almost all my models in that stuff. The only thing I hated was that it was impervious to most solvent cements and had to use either ACC or epoxy to hold anything to it. Well, it's extinct, and I don't have much left. Find something else.
I bought three different kinds of brick sheeting, and the smallest stuff from Walthers - JTT, turned out to be the winner. Base brick color is good if you want that (I don't) but it's easy to work with, cut, and takes solvent cement without a fight. I was going to laminate it but decided to try just reinforcing with styrene and that seems to be working. Only real PITA was putting the windows OUT an additional .010 to get the sill illusion to show better.
Reinforced and propped up together next step is glazing before the walls are permanently attached:
So that brick stuff will be a salvation, but I'm still trying to decide how I'm going to do the roof. The Vollmer 7351 asphalt surface with the ribs 'looks right' but is absurdly difficult to find and expensive with tariffs and fees, Evergreen metal roof 'kits' with the separate ribs are possible but need to be tested, and Evergreen board and batten has better spacing but the battens are too thick.
We'll see how it looks on the end result but for workability and base performance I was pretty impressed with it. You had to look pretty close at the structure to even see it was brick, until it started to shed a little paint toward the end. Will be fully painted.
Back about 1979 or so my girlfriends younger brother Greg Bertolini (later to become my brother in law) made an "O" scale 1:48 model of the building 'as built' in 1861. He did a great job, I was impressed with it, and it's in the local museum today (Wilder museum). At the time I didn't think it looked right at all, until I learned later that it really was and was modified about 10 years later to have wider roofline. His has all the additional gingerbread and that roof cupola, and original red brick.
You can see his model here - in the display case. He was lucky that he actually went over and measured it before destruction, and his is the 'before' model where mine will be the 'after'. Also note that on top is the model of the Irvine(ton) station in 1:48 done by high school students in the early 80's.
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/wilder-museum-irvine?select=9uNvOu8PgVyQq9nEfWt18w
«
Last Edit: October 28, 2026, 02:06:52 PM by randgust
»
Logged
Laughlin Jones
Posts: 19
Respect:
+16
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #12 on:
November 12, 2026, 01:19:28 PM »
0
This is a fun one to follow.
I have done work right around the bend a few times. Never knew what was once there till coming across this thread.
Any plans to have a couple BRPP geeps running past?
Logged
randgust
Crew
Posts: 3289
Respect:
+3010
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #13 on:
November 12, 2026, 01:32:30 PM »
+1
My Ttrak Salamanca Branch modules are generally done in the 1920's, at traffic peak until after WWII. That has been guided by that Sanborn map showing the water tank, and all the structures behind it that will (preview) be on a separate module
The station was taken down before B&P ever existed. And the outer track was taken out.
But toward the end, by 1982-6, the station was really a wreck with partially collapsed roof, boarded up entirely. One of the challenges was that there are few decent photos of it that accurately show the paint scheme, window patterns that had been covered over, etc.
And yet PC still demanded $50K for what really wasn't a very big building for footprint and never got it. It was torn down in '86 under the Allegheny Railroad era.
Construction is hesitated because all those roof supports have to be fitted under a roof. And once you put on the roof, much of the first floor exterior is near inaccessible to paint. So the building has to be detail painted BEFORE the roof panels are figured out, then all those supports.
Logged
SAH
Crew
Posts: 1305
Respect:
+1944
Re: The Warren Piece
«
Reply #14 on:
November 13, 2026, 08:41:05 PM »
0
Really good stuff. Source material, photos, back story - All of it. Great start on the station.
An aside: I grew up in Warren, OH. Always wondered what was in Warren, PA. Never had a reason to go there though.
Logged
Steve Holzheimer
Lakewood, OH
Modeling the AC&Y Spur 4 Serving the Tire Industry
Print
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Up
« previous
next »
TheRailwire
»
General Discussion
»
Layout Engineering Reports
»
The Warren Piece