Eh, forget the strips - just hardwired the trucks! That's what Atlas did, dumping the Kato design.

I'm just kidding of course - I prefer the old-school Kato design.
I think that the factory-made strips are made from spring temper brass, but most hobby brass sheets are not as springy. As mentioned, phosphor bronze is likely better material for home-made strips. Choosing the right thickness is also important. Cutting your own will almost guarantee that the strip will curl during cutting, so some extra effort will be needed to make it flat. Making the shallow Z-bends will also require some care.